← Ελλάδα

Δημόσια Διαβούλευση της ΡΑΑΕΥ σχετικά με την Διαδικασία Επιβεβαίωσης Συμμόρφωσης Μονάδων Ηλεκτροπαραγωγής σύμφωνα με τον Κανονισμό (ΕΕ) 2016/631 [RfG]

Η ΡΑΑΕΥ θέτει σήμερα σε δημόσια διαβούλευση την Διαδικασία Επιβεβαίωσης Συμμόρφωσης Μονάδων Ηλεκτροπαραγωγής κατά RfG, η οποία βασίστηκε στην εισήγηση του Διαχειριστή του ΕΣΜΗΕ, όπως υποβλήθηκε στην Α

Version 1.0 1 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Contents Scope 3

  1. Definitions 3 1.1 1.2 Abbreviations Definitions 3 4
  2. Operational Notification Procedure for New Power Generating Modules 6 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 RfG type definition RfG Operational Notification Procedure Prototype generating units in PPM Type A documents Type B – D main documents Type B – D technical data Type B – D test reports Type B – D simulation model 6 8 14 16 16 17 17 18
  3. Grid connection of generators (RfG) 20 3.1 RfG compliance 3.2 RfG compliance testing and simulation for PGM 3.2.1 Requirement: LFSM-O 3.2.2 Requirement: LFSM-U 3.2.3 FSM 3.2.4 Frequency restoration 3.2.5 Black start capability (if applicable) 3.2.6 Tripping to houseload 3.2.7 Frequency range and Voltage range 3.2.8 Reactive power capability 3.2.9 Active power controllability 3.2.10 Voltage control mode 3.2.11 Reactive power control mode 3.2.12 Power factor control mode 3.2.13 Island operation (if applicable) 3.2.14 FRT (profiles different B/C and D) 3.2.15 Post fault active power recovery 3.2.16 Power Oscillation Damping Control (POD) (if applicable) 3.2.17 Fast fault current injection 20 24 24 29 34 40 42 45 47 52 72 74 78 80 83 85 94 96 107 Annex: Requirements for (O)PPM EMT Simulation models Annex: Requirements for RMS Simulation models 110 118 2 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Scope It is a requirement of each of the Connection Network Codes (CNCs) that equipment, affected by the connection code and connected to the system is compliant with the technical requirements forming part of the CNCs at the time that such equipment is first connected and that it then continues to be compliant throughout its life. This document describes the Compliance Verification Procedure for connection of new Power-Generating Modules (EU regulation 2016/631: NC RfG). The NC RfG has been implemented in the RAE Decision 1165/

, available in the Greek language only.

  1. Definitions 1.1 Abbreviations The following list of abbreviations gives an overview of the most common abbreviations in this document. For further explanation of terminology used, we refer to the relevant regulations and codes. Abbreviation Description CA Connection Agreement CNC Connection Network Code DSO Distribution System Operator CDSO Closed Distribution System Operator DR Demand Response EqC Equipment Certificate EON Energisation Operational Notification ION Interim Operational Notification FON Final Operational Notification LON Limited Operational Notification NC RfG Network Code for Requirements for Grid Connection Applicable to all Generators OPPM Offshore Power Park Module PGFO Power-Generation Facility Owner PGM Power-Generating Module PGMD Power-Generating Module Document GU Generating Unit PPM Power Park Module RSO Relevant System Operator SPGM Synchronous Power Generating Module TSO Transmission System Operator 3 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D 1.2 Definitions The following list of definitions gives an overview of the most common terms in this document. For further explanation of terminology used, we refer to the relevant regulations and codes. Definitions from European Network Codes: • Connection agreement: a contract between the relevant system operator and either the power-generating facility owner, demand facility owner, distribution system operator or HVDC system owner, which includes the relevant site and specific technical requirements for the power-generating facility, demand facility, distribution system, distribution system connection or HVDC system • Connection Point: the interface at which the Power-Generating Module, demand facility, distribution system or HVDC system is connected to a transmission system, offshore network, distribution system, including closed distribution systems, or HVDC system, as identified in the connection agreement • Connection Capacity: the transmission capacity of the connection as stated in the Connection Agreement • Energisation Operational Notification (EON): a notification issued by the relevant system operator to a power-generating facility owner, demand facility owner, distribution system operator or HVDC system owner prior to energisation of its internal network • Interim Operational Notification (ION): a notification issued by the relevant system operator to a power- generating facility owner, demand facility owner, distribution system operator or HVDC system owner which allows them to operate respectively a power-generating module, demand facility, distribution system or HVDC system by using the grid connection for a limited period of time and to initiate compliance tests to ensure compliance with the relevant specifications and requirements • Final Operational Notification (FON): a notification issued by the relevant system operator to a power- generating facility owner, demand facility owner, distribution system operator or HVDC system owner who complies with the relevant specifications and requirements, allowing them to operate respectively a power- generating module, demand facility, distribution system or HVDC system by using the grid connection • Limited Operational Notification (LON): a notification issued by the relevant system operator to a power- generating facility owner, demand facility owner, distribution system operator or HVDC system owner who had previously attained FON status but is temporarily subject to either a significant modification or loss of capability resulting in non-compliance with the relevant specifications and requirements • Installation document: means a simple structured document containing information about a type A Power-Generating Module or a demand unit, with demand response connected below 1000V, and confirming its compliance with the specified requirements • Main Generating Plant: one or more of the principal items of equipment required to convert the primary source of energy into electricity; • Maximum Capacity (Pmax): the maximum continuous active power which a PowerGenerating Module can produce, less any demand associated solely with facilitating the operation of that Power-Generating Module and not fed into the network as specified in the connection agreement or as agreed between the relevant system operator and the Power-Generating Facility Owner • Minimum Regulating Level: the minimum active power, as specified in the connection agreement or as agreed between the relevant system operator and the Power-Generating Facility Owner, down to which the power- generating module can control active power • Power-Generating Module (PGM): either a synchronous Power-Generating Module or a Power Park Module • Synchronous Power-Generating Module (SPGM): an indivisible set of installations which can generate electrical energy such that the frequency of the generated voltage, the generator speed and the frequency of network voltage are in a constant ratio and thus in synchronism • Power Park Module (PPM): a unit or ensemble of units generating electricity, which is either non-synchronously connected to the network or connected through power electronics, and that also has a single Connection Point to a transmission system, distribution system including closed distribution system or HVDC system 4 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D • Offshore Power Park Module (OPPM): a Power Park Module located offshore with an offshore Connection Point • Power-Generating Facility: a facility that converts primary energy into electrical energy and which consists of one or more Power-Generating Modules connected to a network at one or more Connection Points • Power-Generating Facility Owner (PGFO): a natural or legal entity owning a Power- Generating Facility • Power-Generating Module Document (PGMD): a document provided by the PowerGenerating Facility Owner to the relevant system operator for a type B or C PowerGenerating Module which confirms that the power- generating module's compliance with the technical criteria set out in this Regulation has been demonstrated and provides the necessary data and statements, including a statement of compliance • Relevant TSO: the TSO in whose control area a Power-Generating Module, a demand facility, a distribution system or a HVDC system is or will be connected to the network at any voltage level; in Greece the relevant TSO is IPTO (ADMIE) • Relevant System Operator (RSO): the transmission system operator or distribution system operator to whose system a Power-Generating Module, demand facility, distribution system or HVDC system is or will be connected • Statement of compliance: means a document provided by the Power-Generating Facility Owner, demand facility owner, distribution system operator or HVDC system owner to the system operator stating the current status of compliance with the relevant specifications and requirements; Other definitions and clarifications used in this document: • Connected party: either a power-generating facility owner, demand facility owner, distribution system operator or HVDC system owner • Generating Unit (GU): an individual unit of a Power Park Module converting energy into electricity, e.g. a single wind turbine or one or more inverters with solar panels • Dead time (Td): the time from the frequency change event until the beginning of the response • Step response time (Tsr): the time from the change event until the instant the response reaches the tolerance range for the first time • Settling time (Ts): the time from the change event until the instant from where on the corresponding response remains within the tolerance band of the set value • Tolerance: permitted deviation between the declared value of the quantity and the measured value. (IEC IEV reference 411-36-19) • Voltage control mode deadband: an interval used intentionally to make the voltage control unresponsive 5 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D
  2. Operational Notification Procedure for New Power Generating Modules 2.1 RfG type definition The EU regulation 2016/631 (RfG) defines four types of generators A, B, C and D in Article 5 “Determination of significance”, as described in chapter
  3. The fundamental rationale for creating the type definition is that the size of a Power-Generating Module impacts the stability of the grid – the larger one single PGM the more impact. The impact of a large amount of small PGM's (e.g. on frequency stability) is reflected in the requirements. All requirements in the said regulation are cumulative, with some exemptions, sorted into the four types. The compliance testing and simulation of Power-Generating Modules follow the same basic principle. Type identification yes no Pmax < 800 W ? yes Not RfG no Pmax < 1 MW ? yes Type A Equipment Certificate Type B PGMD Type C PGMD Type D EON, ION, FON no Pmax < 20 MW ? yes no Pmax < 75 MW ? yes no Synchronous connection ? SPGM Offshore ? OPPM PPM Figure 3.1 RfG Type identification The following definitions are taken from RfG article 2: • SPGM: Synchronous Power-Generating Module means an indivisible set of installations which can generate electrical energy such that the frequency of the generated voltage, the generator speed and the frequency of network voltage are in a constant ratio and thus in synchronism • PPM: Power Park Module means a unit or ensemble of units generating electricity, which is either non-synchronously connected to the network or connected through power electronics, and that also has a single Connection Point to a transmission system, distribution system including closed distribution system or HVDC system • OPPM: Offshore Power Park module means an AC connected Power Park Module located offshore with an offshore Connection Point. A (power generating) unit is a single generating installation converting energy into electricity. A generating unit in an SPGM may be a gas turbine installation. A generating unit in a PPM may be a single wind turbine, a single inverter with connected photovoltaic cells (PV). 6 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D To these definitions, a conventional power plant is treated as an SPGM. A wind power plant and a PV solar power plant are treated as a PPM. Also a wind power plant with doubly fed induction generators (DFIG) is a PPM, since the generator speed and the frequency of network voltage are not in a constant ratio (see: RfG, article 2, definition 9). An offshore AC connected offshore wind power plant is treated as an OPPM. However, an onshore AC connected offshore wind power plant is treated as a PPM. An offshore power plant that is connected through an HVDCsystem is treated as a DC connected Power Park Module in NC HVDC. Referring to the definitions (paragraph 2.2 of this document) the logical hierarchy is: • Facility o Power-Generating Module (may be Synchronous Power-Generating Module or PPM) ▪ Generating Unit (e.g. Gas turbine, Wind Turbine, PV inverter) The significance of power-generating modules should be based on their size and their effect on the overall system. • Synchronous machines should be classed on the machine size and include all the components of a generating facility that normally run indivisibly, such as separate alternators driven by the separate gas and steam turbines of a single combined-cycle gas turbine installation. For a facility including several such combined-cycle gas turbine installations, each should be assessed on its size, and not on the whole capacity of the facility. • Non- synchronously connected generating units, where they are collected together to form an economic unit and where they have a single connection point should be assessed on their aggregated capacity. Transmission/Distribution Network and connecting bus bar Connection Point Connection Point G W PV GU GU GU's PGM: SPGM PGM: PPM Facility Figure 3.2 Facility, PGM, SPGM and PPM 7 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D 2.2 RfG Operational Notification Procedure This paragraph sets out the requirements for new generators to demonstrate their compliance with the detailed technical specifications for generators, as part of their connection process. The operational notification process sets out the steps through which demonstration of these requirements can be achieved including steady state and dynamic performance. The operational notification process depends on the size and the connection voltage of the Power- Generating Module and thus on their impact on the system. Synchronous machines should be classed on the machine size and include all the components of a generating facility that normally run indivisibly, such as separate alternators driven by the separate gas and steam turbines of a single combined-cycle gas turbine installation. For a facility including several such combined-cycle gas turbine installations, each should be assessed on its size, and not on the whole capacity of the facility. Non- synchronously connected Generating Units, where they are collected together to form an economic unit and where they have a single Connection Point (e.g. wind turbine parks and solar PV parks) should be assessed on their aggregated capacity. The on-shore Power-Generating Modules are subdivided into four types A to D. The operational notification procedure is specified for each type A-D of Power-Generating Module and is broadly as follows: • Type A Power-Generating Modules have a Connection Point below 110 kV and Maximum Capacity between 0.8 kW and 1 MW (not inclusive); • Type B Power-Generating Modules have a Connection Point below 110 kV and Maximum Capacity between 1 MW and 20 MW (not inclusive); • Type C Power-Generating Modules have a Connection Point below 110 kV and Maximum Capacity between 20 MW and 75 MW (not inclusive); • Type D Power-Generating Modules have a Connection Point at 110 kV or above. A Power-Generating Modules is also of type D if its Connection Point is below 110 kV and its Maximum Capacity is at or above 75 MW. For type A an installation document shall include the equipment certificates and other additional information such as source (e.g. PV) and kW rating. Types B, C and D need significant site-specific supporting compliance evidence. For types B and C a Power Generating Module Document (PGMD) is to be provided by the PowerGenerating Facility Owner (PGFO) to the Relevant System Operator (RSO) for each PowerGenerating Module, including a statement of compliance. For type D generators the process is more extensive, due to their scale and potential impact on the system, the extent of the services and technical capabilities that they should be able to provide or demonstrate, and their capability to engage in more detailed testing. Proof of evidence can be provided e.g. by a project certificate containing simulations with validated electrical simulation models. These project certificates should be based on type certificates or/and equipment certificates. Operational notification procedure for PGM Type A For each Power-Generating Module the Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) provides an installation document to the RSO, see paragraph 3.
  4. Any equipment forming part of the installation is to be covered by Equipment Certificates (EqCs) issued by an authorised certifier. Operational notification procedure for PGM Type B, C A Power Generating Module Document (PGMD) is to be provided by the Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) to the Relevant System Operator (RSO) for each Power-Generating Module, including a statement of compliance. The PGMD contains the information that demonstrates compliance with the technical criteria. It shall include test reports and simulation studies reports. The test reports are required by RfG chapters 2-4 of title IV and they include use of actual measured values during testing. The simulation studies reports are required by RfG chapters 5-7 of title IV and they demonstrate steady state and dynamic performance. The PGFO of a PGM type B can, instead of conducting tests, prove compliance with the relevant requirements by means of calculations, based on the, proven by certificates or test reports, properties of the applied components and/or generating units. If a PGM (park) controller is applied, the proper functioning of the park controller in combination with the applied generating units shall be demonstrated. In the case that a prototype generating unit is used in a PPM, see paragraph 3.
  5. 8 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Procedure The PGMD is published on the website of RSO see annex: For each Power-Generating Module within the Power-Generating Facility, the Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) provides a separate independent PGMD to the relevant system operator (RSO), containing the following documents and reports (RfG article 32): • Evidence of an agreement on the protection and control settings relevant to the Connection Point; • Itemised statement of compliance; • Detailed technical data of the PGM as specified by the RSO (i.e. structural data, planning and forecasting data and real time data); • Equipment certificates; • For Type C Power-Generating Modules, simulation models (see paragraph 3.8); • Compliance test reports demonstrating steady-state and dynamic performance; • Studies demonstrating steady-state and dynamic performance. Additional information: • Signed connection agreement; • Protection and settings document (co-ordination with RSO substation protection. The connected party must submit a detailed plan regarding the security resources to the network operator. After assessment and, if necessary, adjustment, the network operator will make one certified copy available to the connected party or his installer; • Signal exchange list (agreed between RSO and PGFO); • Report providing the power quality compliance (according to IEC 61400-21-1:2019); • For type C: Conformity that power quality measurements can and will be performed during the commissioning; • Actual planning information (all relevant planning of notification process information shall be delivered by the PGFO); • An overall testing and commissioning plan. Planning • The PGFO requests connection for a PGM type B or C; this can be on a new connection point or on an existing connection point; • The RSO checks the network capacity; • The RSO sends links to PGMD and Power-Generating Modules compliance verification document to the PGFO; • The RSO informs the PGFO of the relevant network data; the PGFO needs this data to prepare the tests and execute the simulations; • The PGFO hands over the detailed technical data, as specified in the PGMD; • The PGFO hands over a protection and settings document, as specified in the PGMD, a signal exchange list and an overall testing and commissioning plan; • The PGFO hands over the available Equipment Certificates as soon as possible; • The PGFO hands over the results of the simulation studies as soon as possible; • The RSO issues a notification to energise the substation and to connect the powergenerating facility for the purpose of construction and testing activities; • The PGFO hands over the actual planning information and the overall testing and commissioning plan; • Commissioning of the Generating Units of the PGM and the possible plant controller; • Execution of required tests, as specified in chapter 4; • Within a period of two months after energising of the substation and at least three months for PGM <5 MW and at least 6 months for PGM ≥ 5 MW before the desired completion date of the PGM, the PGFO shall submit a preliminary PGMD, accompanied with the preliminary statement of compliance, including reports of test procedures and simulation results; • Within a period of 6 months after the preliminary PGMD, the PGFO shall submit the final PGMD, accompanied with the final statement of compliance, including reports with results of tests and simulation results • In case of a wind or solar powered PPM and in case of a lack of primary solar or wind power due to seasonal influences and with the consequence that the required output power cannot be achieved, the tests shall be postponed until sufficient primary power is available; in this case, the PGFO shall submit a preliminary version of the PGMD at 9 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D least three months before the desired commissioning of the PPM and the final version of the PGMD no later than three months after reaching the full installed PPM capacity; • Within a maximum of two months after receiving the statement of compliance of the Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO), the RSO will respond; • If the assessment of the statement of compliance is positive, the RSO will accept the PGMD; • On acceptance of the complete and adequate PGMD, the RSO issues a final operational notification to the power-generating facility owner • If the RSO does not accept the PGMD, he will send the PGFO the reason for refusal, after which the PGFO will have the option to submit a new version of the PGMD within two months. Operational notification procedure for type D generators For type D the process is more extensive due to their scale and potential impact on the system, the extent of the services and technical capabilities that they should be able to provide or demonstrate, and their capability to engage in more detailed testing. The tests shall be carried out on the complete PGM describing its behaviour at the Connection Point, supplemented with type tests on single Generating Units if applicable or components. If a test cannot be carried out at the Connection Point, e.g., if the function does not exist at PGM control level, the on-site test shall be carried out for a representative sample of each GU type to be installed in the PGM. Alternatively, a single Generating Unit shall be tested and the concerning parameters of all other individual units shall be checked. Figure 3.3 illustrates the connection and commissioning process for a type D PGM. The steps are explained in the following paragraphs. Part of the process is the execution of tests and simulations. According to RfG Article 42

(4)the relevant system operator may participate in the compliance testing. Instead of carrying out the relevant tests or simulations, Power-Generating Facility Owners may rely upon equipment certificates issued by an authorised certifier as part of evidence to demonstrate compliance with the relevant requirements. In such a case, the equipment certificates shall be provided to the relevant system operator, including the Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) if needed. Network connection examination In the case of grid connection of a PGM, the PGFO and the RSO must exchange data in advance. The PGFO specifies the grid connection planning to the Connection Point determined in the course of the rough planning and informs the RSO of the relevant data of the PGM. The RSO needs this "best available" data to include it in the base network model in order to execute preliminary simulations. Thereupon, the RSO informs the PGFO of the relevant network data. The PGFO needs this data to prepare the tests and simulations. NC RfG Article 33 • Energisation operational notification (EON) An EON entitles the facility owner to energise their equipment using their connection but not to generate and is subject to the agreement with the RSO of protection and control settings. • Interim operational notification (ION) An ION entitles the facility owner to operate their Power-Generating Module and to generate for a limited period of time – which is to be specified by the RSO but will be no more than 24 months. Issue of an ION is subject to completion of the data and study review as specified/requested by the RSO including simulation models and studies demonstrating steady state and dynamic performance and details of the intended compliance tests. Tests may be substituted by the provision of Equipment Certificates (EqCs). Simulations can be based on validated equipment models provided by the EqCs. See RfG Article 35. • Final operational notification (FON) A FON signifies the completion of the operational notification process and allows the Power- Generating Facility Owner to operate a Power-Generating Module using their grid connection. • Limited Operational Notification (LON) 10 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D A type D generator holding a FON must inform the RSO with whom they hold a connection agreement in the case that their equipment is affected by a temporary loss of capability, is subject to significant modification affecting performance, or is affected by equipment failure affecting performance, in each case where this is expected to last for more than 3 months. Network connection request Data collection Network Connection Examination Connection commitment by RSO Energisation Operational Notification process • Installation permit • Connection and Transmission Agreement grid connection contract network operation agreement network usage contract • Protection and Setting document • Signal exchange list • Initial measurements • Report proving PQ compliancy • Conformation PQ measurements • Actual planning information • Testing and commissioning plan EON Technical commissioning of network connection & Interim Operational Notification process • Itemised statement of compliance • Detailed technical data • Equipment certificates • Delivery of simulation models • Steady state/dynamic performance • Details and planning of compliance tests • Interim PQ measurements • Interim onsite test ION Trial operation Final Operational Notification process • Final report PQ measurements • Final report onsite tests • Adjustments of simulation models FON Continuous commercial Significant modification or loss of capability affecting the PGM's performance Limited Operational Notification (LON) process • Unresolved issues • Responsibilities and timescales for the expected solution • Possible extension of period of validity or derogation procedure • Possible involvement of the regulatory authority operation LON Figure 3.3 RfG Notification procedure Energisation operational notification (EON) According to RfG Article 34 an EON entitles the facility owner to energise their equipment using 11 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D their connection but not to generate [RfG 35 (ION) entitles to generate power] and is subject to the agreement with the RSO of protection and control settings. Procedure The Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) shall submit a Statement of Compliance to the RSO for issuing an EON. This Statement of Compliance refers to the following documents and reports, all approved by the RSO: • Installation Permit; • Signed Connection Agreement: o grid connection contract; o network operation agreement; o network usage contract; • Protection and settings document; • Signal exchange list; • Initial measurements (power quality)(measurements to be performed after EON is granted and a measuring device shall be in operation one week before energisation of a connection); • Report providing the power quality compliance; • Confirmation that power quality measurements can and will be performed during the commissioning; • Actual planning information; • Overall testing and commissioning plan, including: o Planning of personnel; o Contact details of responsible commissioning manager and authorised personnel; o Planning of active- and reactive power exchanged up to first Generating Unit. Planning • At least 16 months before the date of granting the EON, the PGFO requests the necessary information for the harmonic analysis, after which the RSO makes the required information available to the PGFO as quickly as possible; • A period of minimum 10 months before the date of granting the EON shall be scheduled for review, discussion and approval by the RSO of the report regarding the power quality compliancy; • Within a maximum of four weeks after receiving the Statement of Compliance of the Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO), the RSO will respond. If the assessment of the Statement of Compliance is positive an EON will be granted by the RSO; • The PGFO shall have an EON at least one month before the energization of the connection. Interim operational notification (ION) According to RfG Article 35 an ION entitles the facility owner to operate their Power-Generating Module and to generate for a limited period of time – which is to be specified by the RSO but will be no more than 24 months (an extension of this period may be granted if a request for derogation is made to the RSO before the expiry of that period in accordance with the derogation procedure laid down in RfG article 60 and RAE Decision 778/2018). Issue of an ION is subject to completion of the data and study review as specified/requested by the RSO including simulation models and studies demonstrating steady state and dynamic performance as required by RfG chapters 5-7 of title IV, and details of the intended compliance tests that are to be undertaken to fulfil RfG chapters 2-4 of title IV. After receiving the ION the compliance tests can be executed. Tests may to some extent be substituted by the provision of EqCs. Simulations can be based on validated equipment models provided by the EqCs. Procedure The Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) shall submit a statement of compliance to the RSO for issuing an ION. This statement of compliance refers to the following documents and report, all approved by the RSO: • An EON; • Itemised Statement of Compliance; • Detailed technical data on the Generating Units and the Power-Generating Module; • Equipment certificates in respect of Power-Generating Modules, where they are relied 12 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D upon as part of the evidence of compliance; • Simulation models, as required by the RSO (Annex 4:Technical Guideline on Compliance Simulatons for the Assessment of PGM Technical Requirements); • Simulation studies demonstrating the expected steady-state and dynamic performance as required by RfG Chapter 5, 6 or 7 of Title IV; • Details and planning of compliance tests in accordance with RfG Chapters 2, 3 and 4 of Title IV and approved by the RSO; • Confirmed parameter settings of active power control and voltage control as stated in the connection agreement; • Interim power quality measurements (measurements to be performed after ION is granted and before interim operation starts); • Interim voltage test procedure. Planning • Within a maximum of four weeks after receiving the statement of compliance of the Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO), the RSO will respond. If the assessment of compliance is positive an ION will be granted by the RSO; • The PGFO shall have an ION at least one month before taking the first Generating Unit in operation; • After receiving the ION the compliance tests can be executed. Final operational notification (FON) A FON signifies the completion of the operational notification process and allows the PowerGenerating Facility Owner to operate a Power-Generating Module using their grid connection. To progress a FON the facility owner must have an ION. Completion of the FON is subject to completion of any outstanding requirements set out in the ION and must include submission, by the facility owner, of an itemized statement of compliance and an update of the technical data, studies and models provided as part of the ION but now also validated and using actual values found through testing. In case of an (O)PPM, the Interim Operational Notification (ION) gives the right to produce with a limited amount of Generating Units simultaneously in operation in such a way that the maximum actual output of the (O)PPM does not exceed 20% of the final maximum capacity of the (O)PPM. • If the Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) has completed all the interim tests and measurements with the initial Generation Units to reasonable satisfaction of the RSO, the mentioned power output limitation is cancelled. • Following successful completion of this test each additional Generating Unit should be included in the voltage control scheme as soon as is technically possible (unless the RSO agrees otherwise). • The interim tests can be skipped in case the expected building-time between 20% of full capacity and full capacity is less than one week and if there is enough primary sun power or wind power expected to run the full FON-tests. In that case the FON-tests will be applied only. In case the mentioned building-time appeared to be more than one week the interim tests can still be ordered by the relevant RSO. EON initial measurements, conformity tests and simulations ION conformity tests, simulations and interim PQ measurements Interim tests with limited capacity FON tests and final PQ measurements with full capacity EON granted ION granted Limitation cancelled FON granted In general, the PGFO must have a FON no later than four months after reaching the full installed PGM capacity. FON-tests in particular require a minimum output power of 60 % of the maximum capacity. In case of a wind or solar powered (O)PPM and in case of a lack of primary solar or wind power due to seasonal influences and with the consequence that the required output 13 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D power cannot be achieved, the FON-tests shall be postponed until sufficient primary power is available. In this case, the (O)PPM must have a FON no later than eight months after reaching the full installed (O)PPM capacity. During this delay, the (O)PPM is allowed to operate with a valid ION. Part of the FON should be an agreement between RSO and facility owner, how compliance will be monitored over the life time of the generator, taking into account possible changes in controller software, hardware and also changes in the Connection Point characteristics like short circuit power and frequency impedance characteristics This agreement will be initiated by the RSO and can be assured by a continuous compliance monitoring. Procedure: The Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) shall submit a statement of compliance to the RSO for issuing a FON. This statement of compliance refers to the following documents and reports: • An ION; • Final report on power quality measurements approved by the RSO; • Final report full on-site tests approved by the RSO; • Simulation models, validated against test results (as built); • Motivation and/or re-simulations approved by the RSO, as result of as built values. Planning • Within a maximum of four weeks after receiving the statement of compliance of the Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO), the RSO will respond. If the assessment of compliance is positive a FON will be granted by the RSO; • The PGFO shall ensure that he has a FON no later than four months after reaching full installed PGM capacity; • In case of an (O)PPM, the PGFO may postpone the FON date by a maximum of four extra months if the weather conditions do not allow the required output power for the FON tests. Limited Operational Notification (LON) A type D generator holding a FON must inform the RSO with whom they hold a connection agreement immediately in the case that their equipment is affected by a temporary loss of capability, is subject to significant modification affecting performance, or is affected by equipment failure affecting performance. A LON shall be granted in each case where this is expected to last for more than 3 months (RfG Article 37
(2)). Issue of a LON by the RSO should be subject to identification of the means and timescales by which the non-compliance will be resolved and can last for a maximum of 12 months without requiring a further derogation. A further expansion of the period of validity of the LON may be granted upon a request for a derogation made by the RSO before the expiry of that period, in accordance with the derogation described in RfG Title V. Consequences in case a notification cannot be granted in time In order to maintain system stability the RSO is entitled to: • Refuse energizing of the connection in case an EON cannot be granted a minimum of one month before energization of the connection; • Refuse power production in case an ION cannot be granted a minimum of one month before connection of the first Generating Unit; • Order to limit power production to 20% of the Maximum Capacity of the (O)PPM in case all the interim tests and measurements, mentioned in the ION paragraph have not been completed to reasonable satisfaction of the RSO; • Order to stop power production in case a FON cannot be granted a minimum of four months after reaching full commissioned Power-Generating Module capacity and the ION has been expired. 2.3 Prototype generating units in PPM 14 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D A prototype generating unit is the first power generating unit of a type (and all power generating units of this type that are taken into service within a time period of two years after the commissioning of the first power generating unit of this type) that undergoes significant technical development or innovation. Significant technical developments and innovations occur when components or software versions are changed in such a way that the electrical behaviour on the grid changes significantly. Documentation (see paragraph 3.2) is to be provided by the Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) to the Relevant System Operator (RSO) for each Power-Generating Module (PGM), including a statement of compliance in order to obtain a final operational notification. The documentation contains the information that demonstrates compliance of the PGM with the technical criteria of the NC RfG and RAE Decision 1165/

. The PGFO may use type test reports approved by an independent body or test report included within a certificate of a unit issued by an authorised certifier to demonstrate compliance of the PGM with the relevant requirements. In that case, the type test reports approved by an independent body or test report included within a certificate of a unit shall be provided to the RSO. In case of a prototype generating unit, no unit certificates or type test reports will be available on short notice. In that case, the documentation for demonstrating the compliance of a PPM with the technical criteria of the NC RfG and RAE Decision 1165/

can be based on a prototype confirmation, which is based on a manufacturers declaration and approved by an independent certification body. Within a period of two years after taking into service of the first prototype power generating unit in Greece, a prototype confirmation will be sufficient instead of the type test reports approved by an independent body or test report included within a certificate of a unit. The certification body confirms the existence of a significant technical development or innovation on the basis of a manufacturer's declaration. The certification body also verifies and states in the prototype confirmation that the prototype is principally able to comply with the requirements of the NC RfG and RAE Decision 1165/

. Manufacturer and independent certifying body have the responsibility that the documentation is correct. The prototype confirmation also mentions the expected date of the final type test reports. The generating unit prototype confirmation can be used by the PGFO to demonstrate compliance of the PPM in which the prototype is installed. After approval by the RSO, the PGFO receives a temporary operational notification to start operation. The documentation of the power generating unit specifications shall contain at least: • Electrical data (nominal and rated quantities); • Schematic overview circuit diagram of the power generating unit with all relevant components; • Operating ranges of the power generating unit: o Limits in quasi-static operation; o Reactive power adjustment range; o FRT limit curve; • Protection functions with setting ranges: o Disconnection protection; o Self-protection; • Active power control: o Power/frequency behaviour; o Active power gradient; • Reactive power control; • Fast fault current injection. The manufacturer declares that the prototype generating unit has been designed so that it is principally able to comply with the relevant requirements of the NC RfG and RAE Decision 1165/

. If a prototype confirmation is available based on requirements other than the RAE Decision 1165/

, this prototype confirmation will only be accepted as far as those requirements are equal or more stringent than the RAE Decision 1165/

. For those requirements which are less stringent than the requirements in the RAE Decision 1165/

, an additional statement will be required with the prototype confirmation. Within the period of two years, type test reports approved by an independent body or test report included within a certificate of a unit is required. If after this time period the PGFO is not 15 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D able to hand over the type test reports approved by an independent body or test report included within a certificate of a unit and the resulting declaration of conformity to the relevant system operator (RSO), the RSO is entitled to require taking out of operation the concerned prototype generating units or to disconnect the PGM from the network. This principle, based on NC RfG article 3, will be included in a temporary operational notification for the PGM, issued by the RSO. After accepting the complete and adequate documentation for demonstrating the compliance of the PPM, including the type test reports approved by an independent body or test report included within a certificate of a unit, the extracts of the test reports and the resulting declaration of conformity with the NC RfG and RAE Decision 1165/

, the RSO shall issue the final operational notification to the power-generating facility owner. 2.4 Type A documents According to NC RfG article 30 the operational notification procedure for connection of each new type A power-generating module consists of submitting an installation document. The contents of the installation document are specified by the RSO. The contents are: • the location at which the connection is made; • the date of the connection; • manufacturer and type-identification; • the Maximum Capacity of the installation in kW; • the type of primary energy source (e.g. PV, Wind); • the classification of the Power-Generating Module if it is an emerging technology according to Title VI of the RfG; • capability for electricity storage; • reference to equipment certificates issued by an authorised certifier used for equipment that is in the site installation; • as regards equipment used, for which an equipment certificate has not been received, information shall be provided as directed by the relevant system operator; • the contact details of the Power-Generating Facility Owner and the installer and their signatures. The installation document refers to equipment certificates. The Power-Generating Facility Owner may rely upon equipment certificates. The equipment certificates describe the extent to which the relevant requirements are met. 2.5 Type B – D main documents For PGM type D and, as applicable, for types B and C, the Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) shall hand over to the RSO: • Results and details of physical tests • Results and details of simulations • Technical data • Statement of compliance • Actual planning of: o Energisation, First Generating Unit (in case of a (O)PPM), 20% of the Maximum Capacity of the (O)PPM, and full capacity o In case of type B or C PGM: Delivery of statement of compliance PGMD o In case of type D PGM: Delivery of statement of compliance EON, ION and FON o Delivery of documents on compliancy tests and simulations o Onsite tests In case of type B or C PGM: From the RSO to Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) • Reviews of simulations and test results (PGMD) • Declaration of acceptance of the PGMD (RfG Article 32

(3)). 16 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D In case of type D PGM: From the RSO to Power Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) • Reviews of simulations and test results • Energization operational notification (EON) • Interim operational notification (ION) • Final operational notification (FON). 2.6 Type B – D technical data According to RfG articles 32
(2)and 35
(2)the relevant system operator will request that the power- generating facility owner provides all detailed technical data of the Power-Generating Module with relevance to the grid connection as specified by the relevant system operator (i.e. structural data, planning and forecasting data, real time data). 2.7 Type B – D test reports Type tests may be performed either by an independent test institute, by the PGFO or by the manufacturer. If the type tests are performed by the PGFO or the manufacturer, they need to be witnessed and approved by an independent test institute. In case of a type test, a report (hereafter called ‘Generating Unit test report’) shall cover information from type tests according to FGW TG3-2018 Rv. 25, as well as information on additional tests and information, if required by the RSO. In detail the ‘Generating Unit test report' shall include: • Reactive power capability including PQ and PV diagrams based on measurements; • Report on fault-ride-through capability according to the requirements including measurements; • Report on fast fault current injection tests for an (O)PPM Generating Unit; • Test reports for operation during: o Over and under frequency according to RfG article 13
(1)and RAE Decision 1165/

article 13

(1)(a)(i); o Over and under voltage according to RAE Decision 1165/

article 14

(3)a; (PGM with voltage higher than 1 kV and lower than 110 kV), RfG article 16
(2)and RAE Decision 1165/

article 16 (PGM type D) and RfG article 25

(3)and RAE Decision 1165/

article 25

(1)(OPPM). • Power quality conformity test measurements: o IEC/TR 61000-3-6:2008 (
  1. en)Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) – Part 36: Limits – Assessment of emission limits for the connection of distorting installations to MV, HV and EHV power systems; o IEC TR 61000-2-6:1995 Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) - Part 2: Environment - Section 6: Assessment of the emission levels in the power supply of industrial plants as regards low-frequency conducted disturbances; o IEC/TR 61000-3-7:2008 (
  2. en)Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) – Part 37: Limits – Assessment of emission limits for the connection of fluctuating installations to MV, HV and EHV power systems; o EN-IEC 61400-21-1:2019 (
  3. en)Wind energy generation systems – Part 21-1: Measurement and assessment of electrical characteristics – Wind turbines, paragraph 8.2: Power quality aspects; o IEC/TR 61400-21-3:2019 (
  4. en)Wind energy generation systems Measurement and assessment of electrical characteristics - Wind turbine harmonic model and its application. The Generating Unit test report also applies to other active components, such as flexible alternating current (FACTS) devices, if these components actively contribute by means of control functions to: • The fault-ride-through performance at the Connection Point; • Short and long term operation during over and under frequency as well as over and under voltage. 17 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D The PGFO shall submit simulation studies in the form of a report to demonstrate compliance. In all cases the simulation studies must utilise models applicable to the SPGM, PPM or OPPM with proposed or actual parameter settings. Reports should be submitted in Greek or English with all diagrams and graphs plotted clearly with legible axes and scaling provided to ensure any variations in plotted values is clear. In all cases the simulation studies must be presented as function of time to demonstrate compliance with all applicable requirements. 2.8 Type B – D simulation model Before granting the EON, the PGFO and the RSO must exchange data in advance. The RSO needs this "best available" data to include it in the base network model in order to execute preliminary simulations. Before granting the ION, the simulation (software) models shall be delivered by the PGFO. Before granting the FON, the simulation models shall be updated with as-built data and validated with test results. To perform grid stability calculations, information according RAE Decision 1165/

(i.e. structural data, planning and forecasting data and real time data) shall be delivered for EON/ION, as a result of that: • For type B PGM connected to the transmission-connected closed distribution system: o the simulation model should be adequate to simulate the load flow and shortcircuit behaviour and the LFSM-O function as referred to in RfG articles 51

(2)and 54
(2); o the simulation model is validated against the compliance test for LFSM-O response; • For types C or D PGM and for OPPM: o Full detail simulation model of the PGM up to the Connection Point, including individual Generating Units, transformers, inter-array cabling (in case of a PPM or OPPM), step-up transformer(s), high voltage cables, reactive power compensation equipment (if any), FACTS (if any), and PGM controllers and other active component; o For SPGM: ▪ Dynamic simulation models of exciter, governor, power system stabiliser and any other limiters or controls shall be described by means of generic terms and parameters given by IEC and IEEE series o For PPM and for OPPM: ▪ Full detail simulation model of Generating Unit and PPM controller and any other active component for load flow, short-circuit, harmonic (up to the 50th harmonic order) (only for type D) and dynamic simulations including manual and model controller settings to be applied shall be supplied; ▪ Aggregation of Power-Generating Facility for the simulation model: • the power flow simulation models, fault current simulation models and dynamics simulation models of each PowerGenerating Facility shall be delivered as an entity compiled into a minimum number of single equivalent generators; • the model shall cover – alongside the equivalent generators – the transformers needed to connect the generators and the PowerGenerating Facility to the power system; • this aggregation level should be adequate for the optimal use of the dynamic simulation models for Generating Unit controller and PGM controller; • the aggregated model shall be described by means of generic terms and parameters given by IEC 61400-27 series; o All models shall be delivered in latest versions of both PSS/E and PowerFactory format; o Report on validation of simulation models shall be supplied. o More specifically, the type of PPM models of type C and D and reports that need to be delivered for each model are shown in the table below. Detail requirements can be found in Annex: Requirements for RMS Simulation 18 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D models. Models Generating Unit (GU) and controller model Documents/Reports Full detail PowerFactory User defined GU and PPM simulation model (of PPM) controller model The dynamic study should be delivered based on this model Full detail PSS/E simulation User defined GU and PPM model (of PPM) controller model Benchmarking report of the PSS/E model based on the results of the full detail PowerFactory model for certain study cases (to be agreed with the PGFO) Aggregated PowerFactory Generic GU and simulation model (of PPM) controller model models). PPM (IEC Benchmarking report of the PowerFactory aggregated model based on the results of the full detail PowerFactory model for certain study cases (to be agreed with the PGFO) Generic GU and PPM controller model (WECC models)
  1. Benchmarking report of the PSS/E aggregated model based on the results of the full detail PowerFactory model for certain study cases (to be agreed with the PGFO) Aggregated PSS/E simulation model (of PPM) Validation of the simulation models is a responsibility of the PGFO. Validation can be done by the PGFO himself or by an external expert (manufacturer, consultant). Model validation of wind energy generation systems is the draft for IEC 61400-27-
  2. Model validation of other energy driven systems is expected to follow the same procedure. The PGFO should deliver validation reports of the generating unit model where the simulation results are compared with measurements. For type C and D PGMs, validation reports of both the PowerFactory and the PSS/E generating unit models are required. For type B PGMs connected to transmissionconnected closed distribution system, validation reports of either the PowerFactory or the PSS/E generating unit models are required. • For type D PGM: electromagnetic transient (EMT) models should also be delivered. Detail requirements can be found in Annex: Requirements for EMT Simulation models. Evaluation criteria • Models are delivered as described in this paragraph; • Models will be checked related to data consistency and correct working in the RSO-grid model context. –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– 1 Western Electricity Coordinating Council. These generic models are reduced-order, positive-sequence models suitable for transmission planning studies; the link: https://www.wecc.org/Pages/home.aspx 19 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D
  3. Grid connection of generators (RfG) 3.1 RfG compliance The compliance monitoring (CM) requirements are specified in the EU Regulation 2016/631 (NC RfG) in the articles following Title IV Compliance: Chapter 1 – Compliance monitoring. The compliance testing (CT) and compliance simulation (CS) requirements are specified in EU Regulation 2016/631 (NC RfG) in the articles following Title IV Compliance: Chapters 2-7 – Compliance testing & simulations. RfG Articles 40 to 43 inclusive are about the responsibilities and tasks, in short: • It is the responsibility of the power-generating facility owner to ensure compliance throughout the lifetime of their equipment. The Power-Generating Facility Owner may rely upon equipment certificates • CM procedures are the responsibility of the RSO and TSO • Justification of validity of the applied equipment certificates is a part of the CM activity • The power-generating facility owner is responsible for carrying out the tests in accordance with the conditions laid down in Chapters 2, 3 and 4 of RfG Title IV • To demonstrate compliance with the requirements of this Regulation, the powergenerating facility owner shall provide a report with the simulation results for each individual power- generating module within the power-generating facility • The power-generating facility owner shall produce and provide a validated simulation model for a given power- generating module. Validation can be done by the PGFO himself or by an external expert (manufacturer, consultant). Model validation of wind energy generation systems is the draft for IEC 61400-27-
  4. Model validation of other energy driven systems is expected to follow the same procedure. • The relevant system operator shall provide the power-generating facility owner with technical data and a simulation model of the network, to the extent necessary to carry out the requested simulations in accordance with Chapter 5, 6 or 7 of RfG Title IV. The following table summarises the requirements against which testing and simulation are to be carried out in fulfilment of the requirements of the RfG code. 20 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Simulations Type Type Type RfG Article B C D Offshore Frequency range Testing SPGM / RfG Type Type Type OffPPM B D shore Article C PPM 1) x x x x 13.2 LFSM-O PPM 47.3 x x x 54.2 x x x x 1) 13.2 15.2.c LFSM-O LFSM-U SPGM SPGM 44.2 45.2 x x x x x 51.2 52.2 x x x x x 15.2.c 15.2.d LFSM-U FSM PPM SPGM 48.3 45.3 x x x x x 55.2 52.3 x x x x x 1) 15.2.d FSM PPM 48.4 x x x 55.3 x x x 1) 15.2.e Frequency restoration SPGM 45.4 x x 15.2.e 15.5.a Frequency restoration Black-start capability PPM SPGM 48.5 45.5 x x x x 1) x x 15.5.c Tripping to houseload SPGM 45.6 x x 16.2 Voltage range SPGM 1) 16.2 Voltage range PPM 1) 25.1 Voltage range PPM 1) 18.2.b/c Reactive power capability SPGM 45.7 x x x 21.3.b/c Reactive power capability PPM 48.6 x x x x 15.2.a PPM 48.2 x x x PPM 48.7 x x x 21.3.d Active power controllability Voltage control mode and V2-mode) Reactive power control mode PPM 48.8 x x x 21.3.d Power factor control mode PPM 48.9 x x x 15.5.b Island operation SPGM 15.5.b Island operation PPM 14.3.a Fault-Ride-Through type B SPGM 51.3 14.3.a Fault-Ride-Through type C SPGM 14.3.a Fault-Ride-Through type B PPM 1) 14.3.a Fault-Ride-Through type C PPM 1) 16.3.a Fault-Ride-Through type D SPGM 1) x 16.3 Fault-Ride-Through type D PPM 1) x 17.3 Post fault active power recovery SPGM 51.4 x x x 20.3 Post fault active power recovery PPM 54.5 x x x 19.2 Power Oscillation Damping Control SPGM 53.2 21.3.f Power Oscillation Damping Control PPM 20.2.b Fast fault current injection PPM RfG Article Requirement 13.1 21.3.d x x x x x x x 52.5 x x x 55.6 x x x 52.4 x x 55.4 x x x x 54.4 x 54.4 x x x x x x 56.3 54.3 x x x x x x 55.7 1) x x 53.3 x x x 51.3 x x x x x x x x x 1) required by RSO; not according to RfG The tests apply to the complete PGM. If a test cannot be carried out at the Connection Point, e.g., if the function does not exist at PGM control level or the PGM is too large for existing testing facilities, the on-site test shall be carried out for a representative sample of each GU type to be installed in the PPM or a reasonable alternative test for an SPGM. In the case of a PGM type B the following simplifications may be applied: • Tests at site are not mandatory for PGM with Pmax below 5MW. The tests at site that are mandatory for a PGM with Pmax of 5 MW and above are: o LFSM-O o Reactive power capability o Reconnection after disconnection • Regarding fault-ride-through, fast fault current injection and post fault active power recovery: generating units are type tested on these requirements; if for these requirements unit certificates are available for all generating units in the PGM, simulations to prove compliance with these requirements will not be required by the RSO. • Regarding LFSM-O: generating units and PGM (park) controller are type tested on these requirements; if for these requirements unit certificates are available for all generating units and the (park) controller in the PGM, simulations to prove 21 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D compliance with LFSM-O requirements will not be required by the RSO. In the case of a PGM type B of which each Generating Unit is only controlled by an individual Generating Unit controller and not by a PGM (park) controller, a number of simplifications may be applied: • Regarding reactive power capability, if for this requirement certificates are available for all generating units and other dynamically active components in the PGM, these may be used together with load flow based network calculations to prove the PGM reactive power capability at the connection point; in that case the on-site test for PGM with Pmax ≥ 5MW will not be required by the RSO; • Regarding LFSM-O: generating units are type tested on these requirements; if for these requirements unit certificates are available for all generating units in the PGM, simulations to prove compliance with these requirements will not be required by the RSO. In the case of a PGM type D the following simplifications may be applied: • When Pmax of the PGM is below 10 MW and Pmax is below 50% of the Connection capacity, the tests at site can be limited to those site tests required for Type B PGM Type tests may be performed either by an independent test institute, by the PGFO or by the manufacturer. If the type tests are performed by the PGFO or the manufacturer, they need to be witnessed and approved by an independent test institute. Simulation of the performance of individual Power-Generating Modules within a PowerGenerating Facility shall aim at demonstrating that the requirements of this Regulation have been fulfilled. The scope of the PGM's simulation models is set out in point (c) of RfG Article 15
(6). The level of detail of the network depends on the impact of the PGM on the stability of the power system and on the behaviour of other PGM's. General requirements with regard to instrumentation are specified by RfG article 15
(6), sub (b). General requirements with regard to simulation models are specified by RfG article 15
(6), sub (c). RfG Article 15 specifies general requirements for type C (and cumulative for type D) Power- Generating Modules. RfG article 32 states that simulation models may be requested for type C PGM's to be included in the PGMD. The same article states that for both types B and C the results of simulation studies demonstrating steady-state and dynamic performance as required by RfG Chapters 5, 6 or 7 of Title IV, should be included. So, for both types B and C simulation studies have to be carried out and reported, but for type C also the models should be included in the PGMD. For type D, both simulation studies and the models should be reported. Other general remarks regarding the compliance activities: • A standard review sheet and overall dashboard, issued by the RSO, shall be used. • Actual planning information shall be sent by the PGFO (Power-Generating Facility Owner) to the RSO during the entire compliance process. • The PGFO is responsible to demonstrate compliance regarding the mentioned requirements. Unless stated otherwise, compliance tests, simulations and audits shall apply at the Connection Point. In addition to these tests and simulations, the PGFO shall deliver the structural data. • The PGFO is responsible for the on-site tests, PQ-measurements, simulations and technical specifications. The PGFO shall prepare procedures for the tests for approval to the RSO, including expected active- and reactive power exchanges at the Connection Point, ultimately six weeks before the scheduled date for the on-site tests. The RSO will accept or comment the procedures ultimately three weeks before the scheduled date for the on-site tests. • After approval of the test procedures by the RSO and at least two weeks before the commencement of the test, the PGFO shall provide the RSO with preliminary test dates. Final test dates shall be jointly agreed upon. PGFO shall invite the RSO for witnessing of the tests with a minimum of two calendar weeks' notice. • Test reports shall be submitted to the RSO for approval within four weeks after the test has been performed. • After receipt of each required report as mentioned in the previous paragraphs, the RSO will inform the PGFO within four weeks on approval of the reports. In case a revision of the report is required, the RSO will inform the PGFO within two weeks after receipt of 22 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D the revised report. • After as built values are measured, new simulations with the as built values are to be executed if necessary. The PGFO may submit a motivation to the RSO why execution of the simulations with the as built values is not necessary. Upon receipt of such a motivation the RSO will give a final decision regarding the necessity of new simulations. • The RSO may involve a third party as its representative for the compliance activities (review of procedures, test reports, specifications, simulation studies, statements of compliance, verification of simulation models and witnessing of tests). The RSO will issue the formal notifications (EON, ION, FON). The following paragraphs describe the details of all tests and simulations for SPGM and PPM of types B to D and for OPPM. Application of the tests and simulations depends on the type of PGM. The next table can be used as a reading/application guide with reference to paragraph 4.2 Paragraph 4.2.1 4.2.2 4.2.3 4.2.4 4.2.5 4.2.6 4.2.7 4.2.8 4.2.9 4.2.10 4.2.11 4.2.12 4.2.13 4.2.14 4.2.15 4.2.16 4.2.17 Requirement A LFSM-O x LFSM-U FSM Frequency restoration Black start capability Tripping to houseload Frequency range and Voltage range x Reactive power capability Active power controllability Voltage control mode Reactive power control mode Power factor control mode Island operation FRT (profiles different B/C and D) Post fault active power recovery Power Oscillation Damping Control (POD) Fast fault current injection SPGM B C D x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x A x x PPM B C x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x OPPM D x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x 23 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D 3.2 RfG compliance testing and simulation for PGM 3.2.1 Requirement: LFSM-O Applicable to: SPGM PPM OPPM Type A Type B Type C Type D RfG article: 13
(2)RAE Decision 1165/

article: 13

(2)(f) Test: RfG article 44
(2)(SPGM), 47
(3)(PPM, OPPM) Simulation: RfG article 51
(2)(SPGM), 54
(2)(PPM), OPPM: to be decided by RSO; not according to RfG Requirement to be verified. RfG Article 13
(2): (
  1. a)the Power-Generating Module shall be capable of activating the provision of active power frequency response according to figure 4.4 (RfG figure 1) at a frequency threshold and droop settings specified by the relevant TSO; (
  2. b)instead of the capability referred to in paragraph (a), the relevant TSO may choose to allow within its control area automatic disconnection and reconnection of power- generating modules of Type A at randomised frequencies, ideally uniformly distributed, above a frequency threshold, as determined by the relevant TSO where it is able to demonstrate to the relevant regulatory authority, and with the cooperation of power- generating facility owners, that this has a limited cross-border impact and maintains the same level of operational security in all system states; (
  3. c)the frequency threshold shall be between 50.2 Hz and 50.5 Hz inclusive; (
  4. d)the droop settings shall be between 2 % and 12 %; (
  5. e)the power-generating module shall be capable of activating a power frequency response with an initial delay that is as short as possible. If that delay is greater than two seconds, the power-generating facility owner shall justify the delay, providing technical evidence to the relevant TSO; (
  6. f)the relevant TSO may require that upon reaching minimum regulating level, the powergenerating module be capable of either: (
  7. i)continuing operation at this level; or (
  8. ii)further decreasing active power output; (
  9. g)the power-generating module shall be capable of operating stably during LFSM-O operation. When LFSM-O is active, the LFSM-O setpoint will prevail over any other active power setpoints. From RAE Decision 1165/

Article 13

(2): (
  1. a)the frequency threshold will be set to: 50.2 Hz; (
  2. b)the droop setting is adjustable between 2% and 12%; (
  3. c)the default droop is: 5%; (
  4. d)upon reaching the minimum regulating level, the Power-Generating Module must be capable of continuing operation at this level; (
  5. e)in case of a PPM, Pref, as mentioned in figure 4.4 (RfG figure 1), is equal to the actual active power at the moment the LFSM-O threshold is reached. ENTSO-E recommends the following values for the maximum settling time (Limited frequency sensitive mode; ENTSO-E guidance document for national implementation for network codes on grid connection; 31 January 2018): • active power decrease in case of increasing frequency during LFSM-O/-U activation: o Synchronous power generating modules: ≤ 30 s o Power Park Modules: ≤ 20 s • active power increase in case of decreasing frequency during LFSM-O/-U activation: o Synchronous power generating modules: ≤ 6 min o Power Park Modules: ≤ 30 s 24 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D According to RAE Decision 1165/

Article 13

(2), the PGM shall be capable of continuing operation at its minimum regulating level. So, the active power response shall be provided during the time the frequency is above the threshold value. Policy on Emergency and Restoration (ENTSO-E, 15.02.2022) C-4-3 Frequency deviation management before frequency leader nomination – Activation of Limited Frequency Sensitive Mode (LFSM) In case of LFSM is activated, the FCR providing units’ or FCR providing groups’ LFSM response shall resume from the overall FCR activation as of LFSM intervention. In such a scenario, the FCR providing unit or group shall cumulatively activate its LFSM provision starting from the last FCR set-point calculated at the LFSM triggering. Figure 4.4 Active power frequency response capability of Power-Generating Modules in LFSM-O with droop 5% (RfG figure 1) The relation between frequency, droop and active power change is: With: s2 : LFSM-O frequency droop [%] fn : nominal frequency: 50 Hz f1 : LFSM-O frequency threshold: 50.2 Hz f1 : frequency deviation threshold: f1 = f1 – fn f : frequency deviation to obtain the desired active power change [Hz] P/Pref : change in active power output from the power-generating module [%] as a proportion of Pref In case of an SPGM Pref, as mentioned in figure 4.4 (RfG figure 1), is the maximum capacity (Pmax). In case of a PPM Pref is equal to the actual active power at the moment the LFSM-O threshold is reached. The formula is only valid if the frequency deviation is larger than or equal to the frequency deviation threshold: f ≥ f1. For example, to obtain 8% active power change at a droop setting of 5% and an actual frequency of 50 Hz during test, the frequency change should be 0.4 Hz (0.2 Hz for threshold plus 0.2 Hz). 25 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Objective • • The Power-Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) shall demonstrate the PowerGenerating Module's technical capability to continuously modulate active power to contribute to frequency control in case of any large increase of frequency in the system; The steady-state parameters of controls (such as droop and the power-frequency control threshold value) and dynamic parameters, including frequency step change response shall be verified. LFSM-O tests Test procedure The PGM must be in operation and connected with the network. The test will be carried out by simulating frequency steps and frequency ramps at the PGM’s control input which are sufficiently large to initiate at least 10% of the Maximum Capacity change of the active power, taking into account the droop settings. The frequency shall be varied over the full range from 50.0 Hz to 51.5 Hz. After each frequency step or ramp the PGM should maintain the new operating point for at least 15 minutes (SPGM) or 2 minutes (PPM and OPPM) and until the PGM active power output has stabilised. As stated in RAE Decision 1165/

article 13, the LFSM-O activates above a frequency threshold of 50.2 Hz. The droop shall be set to 5%. At 5% droop a frequency change of 200 mHz above the threshold should cause a change of active power equal to 8% of Pref at the start of the test. This corresponds to 40% Pref per Hz. The test should be performed with curtailed power so that Pref is the same between 50 Hz and 50.2 Hz. In this way it is assured that the changes in active power is only due to frequency variations and not due to primary resource changes. For the performance of the test, there should be no frequency response between 49.8 Hz and 50.2 Hz , so that the provision of primary and secondary control power shall be deactivated. Operating point: • The tests shall be carried out for an initial operating point between the PGM’s Minimum Regulating Level and its Maximum Capacity from which it will be possible to test at least 10% active power decrease. The operating point will be determined in consultation with the RSO. For SPGM the operating point will be 70% of the Maximum Capacity. For a PPM the operating point shall be minimum 60% of the Maximum Capacity. A frequency step response test will be carried out according to the following sequences: Starting frequency (Hz) To frequency (Hz) Power change per step 50.0 50.2 0% 50.2 50.5 -12% 50.5 51.0 -20% 51.0 51.5 -20% 51.5 51.0 +20% 51.0 50.5 +20% 50.5 50.2 +12% 50.2 50.0 0% Refer to figure 4.5. 26 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D The power change is in % of Pref. The new power output may be limited by the Minimum Regulating Level. After each frequency step: • • • • • the initial delay time shall be as short as possible; the maximum settling time in case of increasing frequency must be: 30 s (SPGM); 20 s (PPM and OPPM); the maximum settling time in case of decreasing frequency must be: 6 min (SPGM); 30 s (PPM and OPPM); hold until conditions stabilise; the PGM shall maintain the new operating point for at least 15 minutes (SPGM); 2 minutes (PPM and OPPM). Figure 4.5 LFSM-O test points corresponding to 5% droop The frequency response test will be repeated for frequency ramps with gradients of 0.2 Hz per minute (at 5% droop 8% Pref per minute). Documentation/measurements • • • The simulated frequency, P, Q, V shall be measured as function of the time at the Connection Point; all will be recorded on the same time scale; Applied settings of PGM and GU controller including frequency droop setting; A tolerance band of max. +/- 5% of the measured value will be accepted. Test evaluation criteria The test shall be deemed successful if the following conditions are fulfilled: • • The PGM has not tripped as a consequence of the test during or after the test The frequency threshold is 50.2 Hz • The active power response to a frequency rise at or above 50.2 Hz is according to the droop setting • The initial delay time shall be as short as possible; if the initial response time is beyond 2 s, the PGFO has to offer a reasonably justification to the RSO The settling time is maximum 30 s (SPGM) or 20 s (PPM and OPPM) The PGM maintains each new operating point for 15 minutes (SPGM) or 2 minutes (PPM and OPPM) after each frequency step and frequency ramp Undamped oscillations do not occur after the step change response. • • • LFSM-O Simulations Regarding LFSM-O, generating units are type tested on this requirement. In case of a PPM type B of which each Generating Unit is only controlled by an individual Generating Unit 27 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D controller and not by a PGM (park) controller, if for this requirement certificates are available for all dynamically active equipment in the PPM, simulations to prove compliance with this requirement will not be required by the RSO. In case of a PGM (park) controller, the simulations are always required. The control settings shall be specified to the RSO. Simulation procedure The simulation will be carried out by simulating frequency steps and frequency ramps which are sufficiently large to reduce the active power output to the PGM's Minimum Regulating Level. As stated in RAE Decision 1165/

article: 13

(2), the LFSM-O activates above a frequency threshold of 50.2 Hz. The droop setting is 5%. A frequency change of 200 mHz above the threshold should cause a change of active power equal to 8% of the Maximum Capacity (SPGM) or 8% of Pref (PPM, OPPM). The initial starting point of the simulations are the same as in the tests. • • • • The simulations shall cover the tests for the PGM and prove the validity of the simulation model The simulations will be carried out for the same operating point as was used in the test A frequency step simulation will be carried out: o Starting at 50.0 Hz injection of a frequency step of +200 mHz at the PGM’s control input; o followed by injection of a frequency step of +300 mHz at the PGM’s control input, causing the PGM’s active power to decrease by 12% of Pref; o followed by injection of a frequency step of +500 mHz at the PGM’s control input, causing the PGM’s active power to decrease by 20% of Pref; o followed by injection of a frequency step of +500 mHz at the PGM’s control input, causing the PGM’s active power to decrease by 20% of Pref; o followed by the reverse frequency steps to 50.0 Hz; A frequency ramp simulation will be carried out: o o o o o Starting at 50.0 Hz injection of a frequency ramp from 0 mHz to +200 mHz at 0.2 Hz per minute at the PGM’s control input; followed by injection of a frequency ramp from 0 mHz to +300 mHz at 0.2 Hz per minute at the PGM’s control input, causing the PGM’s active power to decrease by 12% of Pref; followed by injection of a frequency ramp from 0 mHz to +500 mHz at 0.2 Hz per minute at the PGM’s control input, causing the PGM’s active power to decrease by 20% of Pref; followed by injection of a frequency ramp from 0 mHz to +500 mHz at 0.2 Hz per minute at the PGM’s control input, causing the PGM’s active power to decrease by 20% of Pref; followed by the reverse frequency ramps to 50.0 Hz. Simulation evaluation criteria The simulation shall be deemed successful if the following conditions are fulfilled: • • • • • • • The frequency threshold is 50.2 Hz The SPGM active power response to frequency rise above 50.2 Hz is according to the droop setting until the Minimum Regulating Level is reached The PPM and OPPM active power response to frequency rise above 50.2 Hz is according to the droop setting until the Minimum Regulating Level is reached The initial delay time shall be as short as possible; if the initial response time is beyond 2 s, the PGFO has to offer a reasonably justification to the RSO The settling time is maximum 30 s (SPGM) or 20 s (PPM) The simulation model of the Power Park Module is validated against the compliance test for LFSM-O response by expert judgement Undamped oscillations do not occur after the step change response. 28 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D 3.2.2 Requirement: LFSM-U Applicable to: SPGM PPM OPPM Type C Type D RfG article: 15
(2)(c) RAE Decision 1165/

article: 15

(2)Test: RfG article 45
(2)(SPGM), 48
(3)(PPM, OPPM) Simulation: RfG article 52
(2)(SPGM), 55
(2)(PPM), OPPM: required by RSO; not according to RfG Requirement to be verified RfG Article 15
(2)(c): In addition to Article 13
(2), the following requirements shall apply to type C powergenerating modules with regard to limited frequency sensitive mode - underfrequency (LFSM-U): (
  1. i)the Power-Generating Module shall be capable of activating the provision of active power frequency response at a frequency threshold and with a droop specified by the relevant TSO in coordination with the TSOs of the same synchronous area as follows: - the frequency threshold specified by the TSO shall be between 49.8 Hz and 49.5 Hz inclusive, - the droop settings specified by the TSO shall be in the range 2-12 %. This is represented graphically in [RfG] figure 4; (
  2. ii)the actual delivery of active power frequency response in LFSM-U mode shall take into account: - ambient conditions when the response is to be triggered, - - the operating conditions of the Power-Generating Module, in particular limitations on operation near maximum capacity at low frequencies and the respective impact of ambient conditions according to paragraphs 4 and 5 of [RfG] Article 13, and the availability of the primary energy sources. (iii) the activation of active power frequency response by the Power-Generating Module shall not be unduly delayed. In the event of any delay greater than two seconds, the Power-Generating Facility Owner shall justify it to the relevant TSO; (
  3. iv)in LFSM-U mode the Power-Generating Module shall be capable of providing a power increase up to its maximum capacity; (
  4. v)stable operation of the Power-Generating Module during LFSM-U operation shall be ensured;. Pref is the reference active power to which ΔΡ is related and may be specified differently for synchronous power- generating modules and power park modules. ΔΡ is the change in active power output from the power- generating module. fn is the nominal frequency (50 Hz) in the network and Δf is the frequency deviation in the network. At underfrequencies where Δf is below Δf1 the power-generating module has to provide a positive active power output change according to the droop S2. From RAE Decision 1165/

Article 15

(2): (
  1. a)the frequency threshold will be set to: 49.8 Hz; (
  2. b)the droop setting is adjustable between 2% and 12%; (
  3. c)the default droop is: 5%; (
  4. d)in case of a PPM, Pref, as mentioned in figure 4.6 (RfG figure 4), is equal to the actual active power at the moment the LFSM-U threshold is reached. ENTSO-E recommends the following values for the maximum settling time (Limited frequency sensitive mode; ENTSO-E guidance document for national implementation for network codes on grid connection; 31 January 2018): • active power decrease in case of increasing frequency during LFSM-O/-U activation: 29 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D • o Synchronous power generating modules: ≤ 30 s o Power Park Modules: ≤ 20 s active power increase in case of decreasing frequency during LFSM-O/-U activation: o Synchronous power generating modules: ≤ 6 min o Power Park Modules: ≤ 30 s The minimum duration of providing the full active power response after a frequency change shall take into account the availability of the primary energy source. Figure 4.6 Active power frequency response capability of Power-Generating Modules in LFSM-U with droop 5% (RfG figure 4) The relation between frequency, droop and active power change is: With: s2 : LFSM-U frequency droop [%] fn : nominal frequency: 50 Hz f1 : LFSM-U frequency threshold: 49.8 Hz f1 : frequency deviation threshold: f1 = f1 – fn f : frequency deviation to obtain the desired active power change [Hz] P/Pref : change in active power output from the power-generating module [%] as a proportion of Pref In case of an SPGM, Pref, as mentioned in figure 4.6 (RfG figure 4), is the maximum capacity. In case of a PPM, Pref is equal to the actual active power at the moment the LFSM-U threshold is reached. The formula is only valid if the frequency deviation is lower than or equal to the frequency deviation threshold: f ≤ f1. For example, to obtain 8% active power change at a droop setting of 5% and an actual frequency of 50 Hz during test, the frequency deviation should be –0.4 Hz (-0.2 Hz for threshold minus 0.2 Hz). 30 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Objective • • The Power-Generating Facility Owner (PGFO) shall demonstrate the PowerGenerating Module's technical capability to continuously modulate active power to contribute to frequency control in case of any large drop of frequency in the system; The steady-state parameters of regulations (such as droop and the power- frequency control threshold value) and dynamic parameters, including frequency step change response shall be verified. LFSM-U tests Test procedure The PGM must be in operation and connected with the network. In case of an SPGM: the test shall be carried out by simulating appropriate active power load points, with low frequency steps and ramps big enough to trigger active power change of at least 10 % of maximum capacity, taking into account the droop settings and the frequency threshold. If required, simulated frequency deviation signals shall be injected simultaneously into both the speed governor and the load controller references. In case of a PPM: the test shall be carried out by simulating the frequency steps and ramps big enough to trigger at least 10 % of maximum capacity active power change with a starting point of no more than 80 % of maximum capacity, taking into account the droop settings and the frequency threshold. After each frequency step or ramp the PGM should maintain the new operating point for at least 15 minutes (SPGM) or 2 minutes (PPM and OPPM) and until the PGM active power output has stabilised. As stated in RAE Decision 1165/

article: 15

(2), the LFSM-U activates below a frequency threshold of 49,8 Hz. The droop shall be set to 5%. At 5% droop a frequency change of -200 mHz below the threshold should cause a change of active power equal to 10% of Pref at the start of the test. This corresponds to 50% Pref per Hz. For the performance of the test, there should be no frequency response between 49.8 Hz and 50.2 Hz, so that the provision of primary and secondary control power shall be deactivated. Operating point: • The tests shall be carried out for an initial curtailed operating point between the PGM’s Minimum Regulating Level and its Maximum Capacity from which it will be possible to test at least 12% active power increase. The operating point will be determined in consultation with the RSO. For SPGM the default operating point will be 55% of the Maximum Capacity. For a PPM the operating point shall be minimum 45% of the Maximum Capacity A frequency step response test will be carried out according to the following sequences: Starting frequency (Hz) To frequency (Hz) Power change 50.0 49.8 0% 49.8 49.5 +12% 49.5 49.8 -12% 49.8 50.0 0% Refer to figure 4.7. The power change is in % of Pref. The new power output may be limited by the maximum available power output. After each frequency step: • the initial delay time shall be as short as possible; • the maximum settling time in case of increasing frequency must be: 30 s (SPGM); 20 s (PPM and OPPM); 31 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D • • • the maximum settling time in case of decreasing frequency must be: 6 min (SPGM); 30 s (PPM and OPPM); hold until conditions stabilise; the PGM shall maintain the new operating point for at least 15 minutes (SPGM); 2 minutes (PPM and OPPM). Figure 4.7 LFSM-U test points corresponding to 5% droop The frequency response test will be repeated for frequency ramps with gradients of 0,2 Hz per minute (at 5% droop 8% Pref per minute). Documentation/measurements • • • The simulated frequency, P, Q, V shall be measured as function of the time at the Connection Point; all will be recorded on the same time scale; Applied settings of PGM and GU controller including frequency droop setting; A tolerance band of max. +/- 5% of the measured value will be accepted. Test evaluation criteria The test shall be deemed successful if the following conditions are fulfilled: • • The PGM has not tripped as a consequence of the test during or after the test The frequency threshold is 49.8 Hz • The active power response to a frequency drop at or below 49.8 Hz is according to the droop setting The initial delay time shall be as short as possible; if the initial response time is beyond 2 s, the PGFO has to offer a reasonably justification to the RSO The settling time is maximum 6 min (SPGM) or 30 s (PPM and OPPM) The PGM maintains each new operating point for a time that is technical feasible, taking into account the availability of the primary energy source, with a minimum of 15 minutes (SPGM) or 2 minutes (PPM and OPPM) Undamped oscillations do not occur after the step change response. • • • • LFSM-U Simulations Simulation procedure The simulation will be carried out by simulating frequency steps and frequency ramps which are sufficiently large to increase the active power output to the PGM's Maximum Capacity (SPGM) or maximum available active power output (PPM). As stated in RAE Decision 1165/

article: 15

(2), the LFSM-U activates below a frequency threshold of 49.8 Hz. The droop setting is: 5%. A frequency change of -200 mHz 32 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D below the threshold should cause a change of active power equal to 8% of the Maximum Capacity (SPGM) or Pref (PPM). • The simulations shall cover the tests for the PGM and prove the validity of the simulation model • • • The simulations will be carried out for the same operating point as was used in the test A frequency step simulation will be carried out: o Starting at 50.0 Hz injection of a frequency step of -200 mHz at the PGM’s control input; o followed by injection of a frequency step of -300 mHz at the PGM’s control input, causing the PGM’s active power to increase by 12% of Pref; o followed by the reverse frequency steps to 50.0 Hz; A frequency ramp simulation will be carried out: o Starting at 50.0 Hz injection of a frequency ramp from 0 mHz to -200 mHz at 0.2 Hz per minute at the PGM’s control input; o followed by injection of a frequency ramp from 0 mHz to -300 mHz at -0.2 Hz per minute at the PGM’s control input, causing the PGM’s active power to increase by 12%; o followed by the reverse frequency ramps to 50.0 Hz. Simulation evaluation criteria The simulation shall be deemed successful if the following conditions are fulfilled: • • The frequency threshold is 49.8 Hz The droop is 5% • The PGM active power response to frequency drop at or below 49.8 Hz is according to the droop setting until the Maximum Capacity has been reached The initial delay time shall be as short as possible; if the initial response time is beyond 2 s, the PGFO has to offer a reasonably justification to the RSO The settling time is maximum 6 min (SPGM) or 30 s (PPM) The simulation model of the Power Park Module is validated against the compliance test for LFSM-U response by expert judgement Undamped oscillations do not occur after the step change response. • • • • 33 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D 3.2.3 FSM Applicable to: SPGM PPM OPPM Type C Type D RfG article: 15
(2)(d) RAE Decision 1165/

article: 3.24, sub 3 Test: RfG article 45

(3)(SPGM), 48
(4)(PPM, OPPM) Simulation: RfG article 52
(3)(SPGM), 55
(3)(PPM), OPPM: required by RSO; not according to RfG Requirement to be verified RfG Article 15
(2)(d): in addition to point (
  1. c)of paragraph 2, the following shall apply cumulatively when frequency sensitive mode (‘FSM’) is operating: (
  2. i)the power-generating module shall be capable of providing active power frequency response in accordance with the parameters specified by each relevant TSO within the ranges shown in [RfG] Table 4. In specifying those parameters, the relevant TSO shall take account of the following facts: — in case of overfrequency, the active power frequency response is limited by the minimum regulating level, — in case of underfrequency, the active power frequency response is limited by maximum capacity, — the actual delivery of active power frequency response depends on the operating and ambient conditions of the power-generating module when this response is triggered, in particular limitations on operation near maximum capacity at low frequencies according to paragraphs 4 and 5 of [RfG] Article 13 and available primary energy sources; Table 4 Parameters for active power frequency response in FSM (explanation for [RfG] Figure 5) Parameters Ranges Active power range related to maximum capacity |ΔP1|/Pmax 1.5 – 10 % Frequency response insensitivity |Δfi| 10 – 30 mHz |Δfi|/fn 0.02 – 0.06 % Frequency response deadband 0 – 500 mHz Droop s1 2 – 12 % From RAE Decision 1165/

Article 15

(2): The Power-Generating Module shall be capable of providing active power frequency response in accordance with the parameters: (
  1. a)the active power range related to maximum capacity is: 3% (SPGM) and 10% (PPM); (
  2. b)the frequency response insensitivity is: 10 mHz (0.02%); (
  3. c)the frequency response deadband is adjustable from 0 to 500 mHz; (
  4. d)the droop is adjustable from 2% to 12%; (
  5. e)the default droop is 5%; (
  6. f)in case of a PPM, Pref, as mentioned in figure 4.8 (RfG figure 5), is equal to the actual active power at the moment the FSM threshold is reached. 34 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Figure 4.8 Active power frequency response capability of Power-Generating Modules in FSM illustrating the case of zero deadband and insensitivity with droop 5% (RfG figure 5) The relation between frequency, droop and active power change is: With: s1 : FSM frequency droop [%] fn : nominal frequency: 50 Hz f : frequency deviation to obtain the desired active power change [Hz] P/Pref : change in active power output from the power-generating module [%] as a proportion of Pref In case of an SPGM, Pref, as mentioned in figure 4.8 (RfG figure 5), is the maximum capacity. In case of a PPM, Pref is equal to the actual active power at the moment the FSM threshold is reached. For the tests and simulations 5% droop will be set. Delay time and time for full activation of frequency response RfG Article 15
(2)(d)(iv): The initial activation of active power frequency response required shall not be unduly delayed. If the delay in initial activation of active power frequency response is greater than two seconds, the power- generating facility owner shall provide technical evidence demonstrating why a longer time is needed. For power-generating modules without inertia, the relevant TSO may specify a shorter time than two seconds. If the power-generating facility owner cannot meet this requirement they shall provide technical evidence demonstrating why a longer time is needed for the initial activation of active power frequency response; RAE Decision 1165/

article 15

(2): The maximum time for full activation of frequency response is: t2 = 30 s In figure 4.9 (RfG figure 6) Pmax is the maximum capacity to which ΔΡ relates. ΔΡ is the 35 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D change in active power output from the Power-Generating Module. The Power-Generating Module has to provide active power output ΔΡ up to the point ΔΡ1 in accordance with the times t1 and t2 with the values of ΔΡ1, t1 and t2 being specified by the relevant TSO: • t1 is the initial delay and is 2 s or more if justified in line with (EU) 2016/631 t2 is the time for full activation and is specified 30 s. |P|/Pmax • t1 t [s] t2 t [s] Figure 4.9 Active power frequency response capability (RfG figure 6) RfG Article 15
(2)(d)(v): the power-generating module shall be capable of providing full active power frequency response for a period of between 15 and 30 minutes as specified by the relevant TSO. In specifying the period, the TSO shall have regard to active power headroom and primary energy source of the power-generating module; RAE Decision 1165/

article 15

(2): The PGM shall be capable of providing full active power frequency response for a minimum period of 15 minutes (SPGM) or 2 minutes (PPM and OPPM) at each new operating point. Objective • • The test shall demonstrate that the Power-Generating Module is technically capable of continuously modulating active power over the full operating range between Maximum Capacity and Minimum Regulating Level to contribute to frequency control. The steady-state parameters of regulations, such as droop and deadband and dynamic parameters, including robustness through frequency step change response and large, fast frequency deviations shall be verified. FSM Tests Test procedure The PGM must be in operation and connected with the network. The test shall be carried out by simulating frequency steps and ramps big enough to trigger the whole active power frequency response range, taking into account the settings of droop and deadband, as well as the capability to actually increase or decrease active power output from the respective operating point. The FSM will be effective at frequencies between the LFSM thresholds 49.8 Hz and 50.2 Hz: • In case of overfrequency, the active power frequency response is limited by the Minimum Regulating Level, • • in case of underfrequency, the active power frequency response is limited by Maximum Capacity, the actual delivery of active power frequency response depends on the operating 36 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D and ambient conditions of the Power-Generating Module when this response is triggered, in particular limitations on operation near maximum capacity at low frequencies according to paragraphs 4 and 5 of Article 13 and available primary energy sources. After each frequency step or ramp the PGM should maintain the new operating point for at least 15 minutes (SPGM) or 2 minutes (PPM and OPPM) and until the PGM active power output has stabilised. For this test, the frequency response deadband shall be 0 mHz and the droop shall be set to 5%. E.g. at 5% droop a frequency step change of 200 mHz corresponds with 8% active power response. For larger frequency step changes the LFSM-O/U will be active. Operating point: • The tests shall be carried out for an initial curtailed operating point between the PGM’s Minimum Regulating Level and its Maximum Capacity from which it will be possible to test at least 10% active power increase. The operating point will be determined in consultation with the RSO. For SPGM the default operating point will be 70% of the Maximum Capacity. For a PPM the operating point shall be minimum 45% of the Maximum Capacity. During the test we have three different Pref values, one when entering FSM, one when entering LFSM-O and one when entering LFSM-U. This is also shown in table below. Test 1: The following sequences will be executed, using a frequency signal at the PGM’s control input: Starting frequency (Hz) To frequency (Hz) Power change 50.0 50.1 -4% (of Pref,FSM) 50.1 50.2 -4% (of Pref,FSM) 50.2 50.3 -4% (of Pref,LFSMO) 50.3 50.2 +4% (of Pref,LFSMO) 50.2 50.0 +8% (of Pref,FSM) 50.0 49.9 +4% (of Pref,FSM) 49.9 49.8 +4% (of Pref,FSM) 49.8 49.7 +4% (of Pref,LFSMU) 49.7 49.8 -4% (of Pref,LFSMU) 49.8 50.0 -8% (of Pref,FSM) Refer to figure 4.10. The power change is in % of Pref. The new power output may be limited by the maximum available power output or the Minimum Regulating Level. The purpose of executing the test at frequencies above 50.2 Hz and below 49.8 Hz is to demonstrate the capability to successfully transit into the LFSM-O/U modes. The response depends on the LFSM-O/U settings. The power change values in the table assume that the LFSM-O/U droop settings are equal to the FSM droop setting. At each sequence: • After the step maintain the frequency until the active power output of the PGM has stabilized, but at least 15 minutes (SPGM); 2 minutes (PPM and OPPM); • Record the initial delay time t1; • Record the time for full activation time t2 of the frequency response. Test 2: The frequency response test will be repeated for frequency ramps with gradients of 0.2 Hz per minute (corresponding to 8% Pref per minute at 5% droop). 37 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Figure 4.10 FSM test points corresponding to 5% droop Documentation/measurements • Maximum Capacity • • • Active Power set point for each test The simulated frequency shall be measured as function of the time P, Q, V shall be measured as function of the time at the Connection Point; • Record the initial delay time t1; • Record the time for full activation time t2 of the frequency response; • • Applied settings of PGM and GU controller including frequency droop setting; A tolerance band of max. +/- 5% of the measured value will be accepted. Test evaluation criteria The test shall be deemed successful if the following conditions are fulfilled: • • the PGM has not tripped as a consequence of the test during or after the test the activation time of full active power frequency response range as a result of a frequency step change (Test 1) is no longer than 30 s (required by point (d)(iii) of RfG Article 15
(2)and RAE Decision 1165/

Article 15

(2); • the time lag of full active power frequency response as a result of a frequency ramp change (Test 2) is no longer than 30 s (required by point (d)(iii) of RfG Article 15
(2)and RAE Decision 1165/

Article 15

(2); undamped oscillations do not occur after the step change response; The initial delay time shall be as short as possible; if the initial response time is beyond 2 s, the PGFO has to offer a reasonably justification to the RSO; the time for full activation t2 of the frequency response, no longer than 30 s; • • • • the insensitivity of active power frequency response at any relevant operating point does not exceed 10 mHz (point (d) of Article 15
(2). FSM Simulations Simulation procedure The simulation shall be carried out by simulating frequency steps and ramps big enough to trigger the whole active power frequency response range, taking into account the droop settings and the deadband, as well as the capability to actually increase or decrease active power output from the respective operating point. The FSM will be effective at frequencies between the LFSM thresholds 49.8 Hz and 38 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D 50.2 Hz: • • • In case of overfrequency, the active power frequency response is limited by the Minimum Regulating Level, in case of underfrequency, the active power frequency response is limited by Maximum Capacity, the actual delivery of active power frequency response depends on the operating and ambient conditions of the Power-Generating Module when this response is triggered, in particular limitations on operation near maximum capacity at low frequencies according to paragraphs 4 and 5 of Article 13 and available primary energy sources. After each frequency step or ramp the PGM should maintain the new operating point until the PGM active power output has stabilised. For this simulation, the frequency response deadband setting shall be 0 mHz and the droop setting shall be 5%. A frequency step change of 200 mHz corresponds with 8% active power response. For larger frequency step changes the LFSM-O/U will be active. Simulation of step response • The simulation will be carried out for the same active power operating point as was applied in the corresponding test; • The same sequences will be simulated as in the corresponding frequency step test and frequency ramp test; During each simulation: o Simulate until the active power output of the PGM has stabilized o Report the initial delay time t1 o Report the time for full activation time t2 of the frequency response o Report the active power response. • Simulation evaluation criteria The simulation shall be deemed successful if the following conditions are fulfilled: • • • • • • the activation time of full active power frequency response range as a result of a frequency step change is no longer than 30 s (required by point (d)(iii) of RfG Article 15
(2)and RAE Decision 1165/

Article 15

(2); undamped oscillations do not occur after the step change response; The initial delay time shall be as short as possible; ≤2 s for SPGM, ≤1 s for PPM; If the initial response times are beyond these values the PGFO has to offer reasonable justification to the RSO; the time for full activation t2 of the frequency response, no longer than 30 s; the insensitivity of active power frequency response at any relevant operating point does not exceed 10 mHz (point (d) of Article 15
(2)and RAE Decision 1165/

Article 15

(2); The simulation model of the Power Park Module is validated for the tested range against the compliance test for FSM response by expert judgement. 39 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Frequency restoration 3.2.4 Applicable to: SPGM PPM OPPM Type C Type D RfG article: 15
(2)(e) Test: RfG article 45
(4)(SPGM), 48
(5)(PPM, OPPM) Simulation: none Requirement to be verified RfG Article 15
(2): General requirements for type C Power-Generating Modules (e) with regard to frequency restoration control, the Power-Generating Module shall provide functionalities complying with specifications specified by the relevant TSO, aiming at restoring frequency to its nominal value or maintaining power exchange flows between control areas at their scheduled values; The Power-Generating Module has functionalities, as described in RfG article 15
(2)sub (e), that fulfil the requirements of SO GL articles 158 (FRR minimum technical requirements) and 159 (FRR prequalification process). SO GL article 158
(1)sub (
  1. d)and (
  2. f)states: (
  3. b)a FRR providing unit or FRR providing group shall activate FRR in accordance with the setpoint received from the reserve instructing TSO (
  4. d)a FRR providing unit or FRR providing group for automatic FRR shall have an automatic FRR activation delay not exceeding 30 seconds; (
  5. f)a FRR providing unit or FRR providing group for automatic FRR shall be capable of activating its complete automatic reserve capacity on FRR within the automatic FRR full activation time (
  6. g)a FRR providing unit or FRR providing group for manual FRR shall be capable of activating its complete manual reserve capacity on FRR within the manual FRR full activation time Objective To demonstrate the Power-Generating Module's technical capability to participate in frequency restoration control and to check the cooperation of FSM and frequency restoration control. Frequency restoration Tests Test procedure The PGM controller will be triggered with a frequency deviation signal, in order to realise a new operating point according to the PGM frequency-power droop. For the frequency restoration test the PGM controller will be triggered with a different power setpoint and with the frequency deviation signal unchanged, causing the PGM to change its power output in order to contribute to recovery to the rated frequency (speed). The test needs to be performed as follows: • • • • The droop setting is: 5%. While running in FSM, a frequency change of 200 mHz should cause a change of active power equal to 8% of the Maximum Capacity (SPGM) or 8% of Pref (PPM and OPPM). The PGM must be connected with the grid The tests shall be carried out for an initial curtailed operating point between the PGM’s Minimum Regulating Level and its Maximum Capacity from which it will be possible to test at least 20% active power increase. The operating point will be determined in consultation with the RSO. For SPGM the default operating point will be 70% of the Maximum Capacity. For a PPM the operating point shall be minimum 45% of the Maximum CapacityFirst, the PGM controller must be triggered with a -200mHz frequency deviation signal to obtain an active power output rise of 8% of its Maximum Capacity (SPGM) or 8% of Pref (PPM) (from point (50;0) to point (49.8;8.0) in figure 4.11); When the PGM is running stable, the PGM controller must be triggered with a higher active power setpoint (10% of Pref), while remaining the frequency deviation signal, in 40 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D • • • order to contribute to the frequency restoration (from point (49.8;8.0) to point (49.8;18.0) in figure 4.11); Next the frequency shall be increased to 50.0 Hz (from point (49.8;18) to point (50;10)) The last step is to trigger the PGM controller with a lower active setpoint of -10% of Pref. (from point (50.0;10.0) to point (50.0;0)) At each test step hold for at least 15 minutes (SPGM); 2 minutes (PPM and OPPM); Figure 4.11 Frequency restoration test points corresponding to 5% droop Documentation/measurements The following signals (as function of time) should be recorded as a minimum: • • • • the grid frequency or turbine speed; the frequency change injection signal; the active power setpoint; the active power at the Connection Point. Test evaluation criteria The test shall be deemed successful if the results, for both dynamic and static parameters, comply with the requirements of point (
  7. e)of Article 15
(2): • The PGM is technically capable to participate in Frequency Restoration Reserve (FRR) • The FRR activation delay shall not exceed 30 seconds. 41 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Black start capability (if applicable) 3.2.5 Applicable to: SPGM Type C Type D RfG article: 15
(5)(a) NC ER 2017/2196 Test: RfG article 45
(5)(SPGM) Simulation: if required by TSO Requirement to be verified Article 15: General requirements for type C Power-Generating Modules 5. Type C Power-Generating Modules shall fulfil the following requirements relating to system restoration: (
  1. a)with regard to black start capability: (
  2. i)black start capability is not mandatory without prejudice to the Member State's rights to introduce obligatory rules in order to ensure system security; (
  3. ii)Power-Generating Facility Owners shall, at the request of the relevant TSO, provide a quotation for providing black start capability. The relevant TSO may make such a request if it considers system security to be at risk due to a lack of black start capability in its control area; (iii) a Power-Generating Module with black start capability shall be capable of starting from shutdown without any external electrical energy supply within a time frame specified by the relevant system operator in coordination with the relevant TSO; (
  4. iv)a Power-Generating Module with black start capability shall be able to synchronise within the frequency limits laid down in point (
  5. a)of Article 13
(1)and, where applicable, voltage limits specified by the relevant system operator or in Article 16
(2); (
  1. v)a Power-Generating Module with black start capability shall be capable of automatically regulating dips in voltage caused by connection of demand; (
  2. vi)a Power-Generating Module with black start capability shall: - be capable of regulating load connections in block load, - be capable of operating in LFSM-O and LFSM-U, as specified in point (
  3. c)of [RfG article 15] paragraph 2 and [RfG] Article 13
(2), control frequency in case of overfrequency and underfrequency within the whole active power output range between minimum regulating level and maximum capacity as well as at houseload level, be capable of parallel operation of a few Power-Generating Modules within one island, and control voltage automatically during the system restoration phase; - - The frequency limits laid down in RAE Decision 1165/

Article 13(1) are: 47.5 Hz – 51.5 Hz.

The voltage limits laid down by the RSO are: • type C 0.90 pu – 1.10 pu; The voltage limits laid down in RfG Article 16

(2)for unlimited time are: • • type D 110 kV up to 300 kV: 0.90 pu – 1.118 pu; type D 300 kV to 400 kV: 0.90 pu – 1.05 pu. The PGM with black-start functionality is capable to start from a complete shutdown according to the specifications published by the RSO. The PGM with black-start functionality is capable to synchronise according to the specifications published by the RSO. The TSO acquires black-start possibilities in a size to be determined by him. He determines the preferred locations and he uses the product specifications as referred to in Article 4, 42 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D second paragraph, part b, of the NC ER. Objective With regard to the black start capability test the following requirements shall apply: • • • • • for a PGM with black start capability, this technical capability to start from shut down without any external electrical energy supply shall be demonstrated; to demonstrate that the PGM is able to energise a de-energised substation to demonstrate that the PGM is able to energise a de-energised network as indicated by the TSO to demonstrate that the PGM is able to run at low load during a significant time to demonstrate that the PGM is able to synchronise with and be paralleled with a network that is operating within the limits of RfG article 13
(1)and RfG article 16
(2)at an off-nominal frequency and voltage. Black start capability Tests The black-start test will be executed at least once per calendar year. Test procedure • • All steps including all necessary switching actions are laid down in the detailed test protocol as part of the black start agreement; The PGM with black start capability must be at complete standstill during at least 4 hours, without any connection to the Connection Point or any other external electrical energy supply; o All the auxiliary gas turbines and/or auxiliary diesel engines in the facility in which that PGM with black start capability is situated, shall be shut down; o • • • • • • • The relevant PGM with black start capability shall be de-loaded and desynchronised and all alternating current electrical supplies to its auxiliary system shall be disconnected; The emergency generator may start automatically; The auxiliary gas turbine(
  1. s)or auxiliary diesel engine(
  2. s)to the relevant PGM with black start capability shall be started, and shall re-energise the auxiliary system of the relevant PGM; Energise the step-up transformer according to the energising method that is described in the detailed test protocol; The relevant PGM will be capable to connect to a de-energised RSO bus bar and to maintain this section at a stable voltage of 100% Un ; Energise the designated network section according to the energising method that is described in the detailed test protocol; The relevant PGM with black start capability shall be synchronised to the system; In accordance with the RSO the relevant PGM will be powered up to an agreed active power output. Documentation/measurements The following signals (as function of time) should be recorded as a minimum: • • • • • • speed, voltage, active and reactive power output of auxiliary gas turbine/diesel generators for Black Start function; terminal voltages of auxiliary MV and LV switchgear; auxiliary power output of emergency generators; turbine speed, -terminal voltage and active and reactive power output of the (gas)turbine that is started; active and reactive power output of the (gas)turbine that is started at the Connection Point; voltage and frequency at the Connection Point. Test evaluation criteria • The PGM with black start capability successfully: o o energises the designated network section to be energised; injects or absorbs the reactive power of the designated network section to be 43 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D energised; in island mode maintains the energised network section at a stable voltage of 100% Un; o synchronising and paralleling to the public network o outputs active power according to the black-start agreement; o powers up to the minimum regulating level with a mean increment as stated in the Black Start agreement; o increases the active power output to the agreed level. The test shall be deemed successful if the start-up time is kept within the time frame set out in the blackstart agreement and if the PGM runs stable. o • Black start capability simulation The TSO can request the PGFO to conduct a simulation study to demonstrate the capability to energise the TSO network. 44 RfG compliance verification for Power generating modules types A, B, C and D Tripping to houseload 3.2.6 Applicable to: SPGM Type C Type D RfG article: 15
(5)(c) RAE Decision 1165/2020 article 15
(5); Test: RfG article 45
(6)(SPGM) Simulation: none Requirement to be verified RfG Article 15: General requirements for type C Power-Generating Modules; also applicable to type D: 5. Type C Power-Generating Modules shall fulf

🔗 Στην επίσημη πηγή

Επεξήγηση AI βάσει του επίσημου κειμένου του νόμου. Ενδεικτική, δεν υποκαθιστά νομική συμβουλή.