Official sourcesirishstatutebook.ie · EUR-Lex
Europaius

Insurance claim refused in Ireland: how to challenge it

A refused or reduced insurance claim usually comes with a letter citing non-disclosure, a policy exclusion, late notification or a suspicion of fraud. For consumers in Ireland, the Consumer Insurance Contracts Act 2019 changed the rules on most of these points. You no longer have a general duty to volunteer information: your duty is to answer the insurer's specific questions honestly and with reasonable care (section 8). An innocent mistake does not entitle the insurer to refuse the claim, and a careless one only allows a proportionate response (section 9). Late notification that does not prejudice the insurer is not on its own a reason to refuse (section 16(3)). Old-style warranties and "basis of contract" clauses no longer work (section 19). If the insurer will not move after its internal complaints process, the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman can investigate, direct the insurer to pay and award compensation of up to €500,000. This guide applies to consumers, meaning individuals and small businesses within the Act's definition, insuring their home, car, health, travel, life or contents. It explains how to test the insurer's reasons, how to complain and escalate, and which deadlines matter.

Insurance · refused claims

Key facts

Deadline
A complaint to the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman must generally be made within 6 years of the conduct complained of, here the refusal of the claim (section 51(1) of the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman Act…
Area of law
Insurance · refused claims
Steps
Last updated
22/11/2026

Deadline

A complaint to the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman must generally be made within 6 years of the conduct complained of, here the refusal of the claim (section 51(1) of the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman Act 2017); the period is suspended while the insurer's internal complaints process runs (section 54(2)).

Other time points: notify a claim within the period in the policy or, if none, within a reasonable time (section 16(2) of the 2019 Act). A party may appeal an Ombudsman decision to the High Court within 35 days of notification (section 64(2) of the 2017 Act). Court proceedings for breach of the insurance contract must generally issue within 6 years of the breach (section 11 of the Statute of Limitations 1957). The duties of disclosure in sections 8 and 9 of the 2019 Act apply from 1 September 2021, most other sections from 1 September 2020 (S.I. 329/2020), and section 18(4) on co-insured innocent parties from 13 May 2026 (S.I. 203/2026).

What to do

  1. Get the refusal and the reasons in writing. Ask the insurer for a written decision that states the reason for refusing or reducing the claim and the policy wording it relies on. Under section 16(4) of the Consumer Insurance Contracts Act 2019 the insurer must handle claims promptly and fairly, engage with you and, when a claim is settled or disposed of, tell you the amount and the reasons. Ask also for a copy of your proposal form or online application, any recorded phone calls at the time of sale, the policy schedule in force on the date of loss, and any loss adjuster's or investigator's report. You can request your personal data, including notes and recordings, under the GDPR if they are not provided voluntarily.
  2. Identify which type of refusal you are facing. Most refusals fall into four groups: (1) alleged non-disclosure or misrepresentation at the time you took out or renewed the policy; (2) an exclusion or a condition of the policy; (3) late notification or failure to cooperate with the investigation; (4) alleged fraud. Each group has its own rules under the 2019 Act, and the answer to the insurer depends on which one applies. Read the clause quoted in the letter against the full policy wording, including definitions. Where the wording is ambiguous, the interpretation most favourable to the consumer prevails, and the European Communities (Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts) Regulations 1995 apply to consumer insurance contracts (section 20).
  3. If the insurer says you failed to disclose something, test it against sections 8 and 9. Your pre-contractual duty is confined to answering the insurer's questions; you need not volunteer anything else (section 8(2)). The insurer must ask specific questions, not general ones (section 8(3)), in plain language, and any ambiguity is read in your favour (section 8(5)). It can rely on a non-disclosure only if it shows that it was an effective cause of the insurer entering into the contract on the terms it did (section 8(6)). If your answer was innocent, the insurer must pay (section 9(2)). If it was careless, the remedy must be proportionate: refusal only if the insurer would not have insured you at all, otherwise different terms or a proportionate reduction of the claim (section 9(4)).
  4. If the insurer relies on an exclusion, a condition or a warranty, check whether it still bites. Statements you made about facts or opinions take effect only as representations, and clauses that turn them into warranties, including "basis of contract" clauses, are invalid (section 19(2) and (3)). A term that imposes a continuing restriction on you during the policy suspends cover only while the breach lasts, and does not suspend it at all if the breach did not increase the risk of the loss that occurred (section 19(4) and (5)). For property claims, an exclusion for criminal or intentional damage now applies only to the person who caused, colluded in or consented to it, not to an innocent co-insured (section 18(4), in force since 13 May 2026). Section 17 limits an insurer's ability to withhold payment until repair or reinstatement work is complete.
  5. If the issue is late notification or cooperation, focus on prejudice. You must notify an insured event within a reasonable time or within the period set by the policy, and cooperate with the investigation by answering reasonable requests honestly (section 16(1) and (2)). However, where late notification has not prejudiced the insurer, it cannot refuse the claim on that ground alone (section 16(3)). Write to the insurer explaining when you became aware of the loss, when you notified it and why the delay made no difference to its ability to investigate, for example because the damage was photographed and the damaged items kept. If part of the claim is quantified, the insurer must pay that part within a reasonable time even while the rest is still being assessed (section 16(9)).
  6. If the insurer alleges fraud, take advice early. Where a claim contains information that is false or misleading in a material respect, and you knew it or consciously disregarded it, the insurer may refuse that claim and terminate the policy (section 18(1)). It may also treat the contract as ended from the date of the fraudulent claim and keep the premiums (section 18(3)). A genuine earlier claim under the same policy is not affected by a later fraudulent one (section 18(2)). An exaggerated estimate made in good faith is not fraud. Ask the insurer to identify precisely what it says is false and on what evidence. A fraud allegation can affect future cover and may be reported, so consider a solicitor before you reply.
  7. Make a formal complaint to the insurer. Write to the insurer's complaints department, not only the claims handler, and say that you are making a complaint. State the claim number, the reason given for refusal, why it is wrong by reference to the sections above, and what you want: payment in full, a recalculation or a review. Attach your evidence. Regulated insurers must run an internal complaints procedure under the Central Bank's Consumer Protection Code and give you a final response letter that tells you about your right to go to the Ombudsman. The Ombudsman may decline to investigate if the insurer has not had a reasonable opportunity to deal with the complaint (sections 44(2)(b) and 54(1) of the 2017 Act), so do not skip this step.
  8. Complain to the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman. If the final response does not resolve the matter, or the insurer fails to complete its process, complain to the Ombudsman online or on its complaint form, attaching the final response letter, the policy, your correspondence and evidence. The Ombudsman's service is free and it may first try mediation. On investigation it decides whether the complaint is upheld, substantially upheld, partially upheld or rejected, on grounds that include conduct that was contrary to law or unreasonable, unjust or oppressive (section 60(2) of the 2017 Act). It can direct the insurer to rectify the conduct and to pay compensation of up to €500,000 (section 60(4) and S.I. 154/2018). The Ombudsman will not investigate where court proceedings on the same matter have been issued (section 50(3)(b)).
  9. Decide on court proceedings or an appeal. Either party may appeal the Ombudsman's decision to the High Court within 35 days of notification (section 64(2) of the 2017 Act); the court can affirm, set aside or remit the decision. If you prefer to sue the insurer for breach of contract instead of going to the Ombudsman, you choose one route: once proceedings are issued, the Ombudsman cannot investigate. The court with jurisdiction depends on the value of the claim. Check whether the policy contains an arbitration clause and take advice on its effect. Contract claims must generally issue within 6 years (section 11 of the Statute of Limitations 1957). Where cover was refused under a liability policy and the insured cannot be found or is insolvent, an injured third party can sometimes claim against the insurer directly (section 21 of the 2019 Act).

What to watch out for

Legal basis

8
This law reforms the rules for consumer insurance contracts, aiming to update and clarify the legal framework governing agreements between insurers…
Is éard atá sa dlí seo ná Oifig an Ombudsman um Sheirbhísí Airgeadais agus Pinsean a bhunú, agus leagann sé amach a fheidhmeanna, lena n-áirítear nós…
Is éard atá sa dlí seo ná forálacha éagsúla a bhaineann le hárachas, lena n-áirítear bailiú faisnéise ag an mBanc Ceannais, tuarascálacha ar…
Is éard atá sa dlí seo ná leasú ar an Acht um an Ombudsman Seirbhísí Airgeadais agus Pinsean 2017, ag déanamh forálacha maidir le ríomh caiteachas…
This law, the Statute of Limitations, 1957, sets time limits for bringing various legal actions and arbitrations.

Frequently asked questions

10
What can I do if my insurance claim is rejected in Ireland?

Ask for the reasons in writing, check them against the Consumer Insurance Contracts Act 2019, and make a written complaint to the insurer. If the final response does not resolve it, complain to the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman, which is free and can direct the insurer to pay and award compensation of up to €500,000.

Can an insurer refuse a claim for something I did not tell them?

For consumer policies under the 2019 Act, your duty is to answer the insurer's specific questions honestly and with reasonable care. You do not have to volunteer other information (section 8(2)). If the insurer never asked, it generally cannot refuse the claim for non-disclosure.

What happens if I made an honest mistake on my insurance application?

If you answered honestly and with reasonable care and the mistake was innocent, the insurer must pay the claim and cannot avoid the policy (section 9(2)). If you were careless, the insurer's remedy must be proportionate, such as reducing the payout in line with the extra premium it would have charged.

Can my insurer refuse a claim because I reported it late?

Not on that ground alone if the delay did not prejudice the insurer (section 16(3) of the 2019 Act). You still have to notify within a reasonable time or the policy period, so explain why the delay made no difference to the insurer's investigation.

How long does the insurer have to pay a claim?

The Act does not set a fixed number of days: the insurer must pay sums due within a reasonable time, and pay any part of the claim already quantified while the rest is assessed (section 16(8) and (9)). Unreasonable delay is itself a ground for complaint to the Ombudsman.

How do I complain to the Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman?

First complete the insurer's internal complaints process and get its final response letter. Then complain online or on the Ombudsman's form, attaching the letter, the policy and your evidence. The complaint should be made within six years of the conduct, and the period is paused during the insurer's internal process.

Is the Ombudsman's decision binding on the insurer?

Yes. A decision is binding on the parties to the complaint (section 62(1) of the 2017 Act), subject only to an appeal to the High Court within 35 days of notification (section 64). If no appeal is brought, the insurer must comply with any direction to pay or rectify.

What is the maximum compensation the FSPO can award?

Section 60(5) of the 2017 Act set €250,000, but S.I. 154/2018 raised the maximum to €500,000 for complaints other than annuities, and €52,000 a year for annuities. Larger claims need to be brought in court.

My partner damaged our house deliberately. Can the insurer refuse my claim too?

Since 13 May 2026, an exclusion for criminal or intentional damage applies only to the person who caused, colluded in or consented to it (section 18(4) of the 2019 Act). An innocent co-insured can claim their proportionate share, but must cooperate, for example by giving a statutory declaration.

Can I sue my insurance company instead of going to the Ombudsman?

Yes, but you must choose. Once court proceedings on the same matter are issued, the Ombudsman cannot investigate (section 50(3)(b)). Court is usually slower and costs can be awarded against you, while the Ombudsman is free. Contract claims must generally be issued within six years.

Practical legal guides

6

Analyse my document →Legal guideContract templatesCountry home page

Last updated: · Sources: Consumer Insurance Contracts Act 2019 – s. 8, 9, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman Act 2017 – s. 44, 50, 51, 54, 60, 62, 64, S.I. 154/2018 – Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman (Compensation) Regulations 2018 (limit €500,000), S.I. 329/2020 – Consumer Insurance Contracts Act 2019 (Commencement) Order 2020, irishstatutebook.ie, EUR-Lex

Explanations are generated from the official legal text and are indicative; only the full text, which every page links to, is binding. Europaius provides legal information, not legal services.