Ending a contract when the other side does not perform (Malta)
Under Maltese law a contract that has been validly made "has the force of law" between the parties and can only be revoked by mutual consent or on grounds allowed by law (article 992 of the Civil Code, Cap. 16). The most common ground is non-performance. Every bilateral contract carries an implied resolutive condition: if one party fails to fulfil its engagement, the other may ask for the contract to be dissolved, or insist on performance, and in either case claim damages (articles 1068 and 1069). The catch is that, unless the contract contains an express resolutive clause, dissolution is not automatic. It has to be demanded from the court, which may still give the defaulting party a reasonable time to perform. This guide is for buyers and sellers, people who paid a contractor or supplier who never delivered, and businesses stuck in a contract the other side has stopped honouring. It explains how to check what the contract says, how to put the other party in default with a judicial letter, which court to go to, how to recover what you paid and what you can claim on top. It also covers the separate case of a contract tainted by error, fraud or violence, where the remedy is rescission within two years. If you only want to cancel an online purchase within 14 days, that is a different consumer right with its own guide.
Key facts
Deadline
There is no single deadline for asking a court to dissolve a contract for non-performance: the action follows the ordinary prescription rules, in most commercial and money claims five years (article 2156 Cap. 16), otherwise the general thirty years (article 2143). Rescission for error, fraud or violence is barred after two years from discovery of the defect or the end of the violence (articles 1222 and 1223). Latent defects in goods: six months from delivery for movables, one year from the contract for immovables (article 1431). An unpaid seller of movables who wants the goods back must act within fifteen days of delivery (article 1439).
What to do
Read the contract for an express resolutive clause.
Look for wording such as "this agreement shall be automatically terminated if…" or "the agreement shall be dissolved ipso jure upon…". If such an express resolutive condition exists and the event has happened, the contract is dissolved by operation of law and the court may not grant the defaulting party extra time (article 1067 Cap. 16). If there is no such clause, you rely on the condition implied in every bilateral contract (article 1068), and dissolution must be pronounced by the court. Note also any penalty clause: where the contract fixes the damages payable on breach, the court may not award more or less than that sum (article 1138). Write down which obligation was broken, the date it was due and any time limit the contract sets.
Decide what you actually want: performance or dissolution.
Article 1069 gives the innocent party a choice. You can demand that the other side be compelled to perform, if performance is still possible, or you can demand dissolution, which puts both parties back in the position they were in before the contract (article 1066). In both cases you may also claim damages. The choice matters: if you ask for performance and the work is half done, you keep the contract alive; if you ask for dissolution, you must be ready to return what you received. For obligations "to do", the court can also authorise you to have the work completed by someone else at the debtor's expense (article 1127). Decide before you send anything, because your letters will be read as evidence of what you elected.
Put the other party formally in default.
Where the contract fixes a date for performance, the debtor is in default by the mere lapse of that date (article 1130(1) Cap. 16). Where no date is fixed, the debtor is only put in default by an intimation made by a judicial act (article 1130(2)). In practice this is a judicial letter (ittra uffiċjali) or a judicial protest filed in the court registry and served by the court marshal; under article 889 of the Code of Organization and Civil Procedure (Cap. 12) a judicial letter may be used where the law simply requires a judicial act. State the obligation, the breach, a final period to perform and that you will otherwise sue for dissolution and damages. A judicial letter also interrupts prescription from the day it is filed, provided it is served or published as article 891 Cap. 12 requires. Registry fees are set in Tariff B of Cap. 12; check the current amount at the registry.
Collect the evidence of the contract and the breach.
The party claiming dissolution must prove the contract, its terms and the other side's failure. Gather the signed contract or, for informal deals, emails, messages, quotations and invoices; proof of every payment (bank transfers rather than cash); photographs and dated notes of incomplete or defective work; the judicial letter and any reply. If the dispute is technical, for example building works or a defective machine, consider a report by an independent expert before the work is altered, because the court will usually appoint its own referee and will want to see the original state. If the other party claims the delay was caused by force majeure, remember that the burden is on the debtor to prove an extraneous cause not imputable to him (articles 1133 and 1134).
Choose the right forum.
If you only want money back and the claim does not exceed €5,000, the Small Claims Tribunal hears money claims up to that amount under a simplified procedure, without the need for a lawyer (article 3 of the Small Claims Tribunal Act, Cap. 380). It cannot hear disputes on ownership of immovable property. Claims up to €15,000 against persons living in Malta go to the Court of Magistrates (article 47 Cap. 12); larger claims, and any claim that requires the court to declare a contract dissolved together with restitution and damages above that value, go to the Civil Court, First Hall, by sworn application. Cases involving ownership of immovables are outside the Magistrates' jurisdiction whatever their value (article 47(3)). In Gozo the Court of Magistrates (Gozo) has the corresponding competence.
File the claim and ask for dissolution, restitution and damages.
The sworn application should ask the court to declare the contract dissolved because of the defendant's non-performance (articles 1068 and 1069 Cap. 16), to order the return of the price or deposit paid, and to condemn the defendant in damages. Damages cover the loss suffered and the profit lost (article 1135), limited to what was foreseeable when the contract was made unless the defendant acted fraudulently (article 1136). Where the claim is for a sum of money, the damages for delay consist of interest at 8% a year (article 1139); for ordinary civil debts this runs from a judicial demand, for commercial obligations from the due date (article 1141). If the debt is certain, liquidated, due and not above €25,000, the special procedure under article 166A Cap. 12 can turn a sworn judicial letter into an executive title if the debtor does not reply within thirty days.
Expect the court to consider a period of grace.
Because the implied resolutive condition does not operate ipso jure, the court may, according to the circumstances, grant the defendant a reasonable time to perform (proviso to article 1068 Cap. 16). Judges look at how serious the breach is, whether it goes to the heart of the contract, how long the delay has lasted and whether the claimant's own conduct contributed. Be ready to show why further time would be pointless, for example because the date was essential, the goods are perishable, or you have already had to buy elsewhere. If you yourself have not paid what you owed, expect the defendant to argue that he was entitled to withhold performance: a seller, for instance, is not bound to deliver if the buyer does not pay, unless credit was given (article 1391).
Apply the special rules if the contract is a sale.
For sales the Civil Code adds specific remedies. If the seller fails to deliver on time, the buyer may choose between dissolution and being put in possession, provided the delay is due solely to the seller, and may claim damages (articles 1385 and 1386). If the goods delivered are not of the quality promised or do not match the sample, the buyer may reject them and claim damages or accept them at a reduced price (article 1390). Latent defects give the actio redhibitoria (return and refund) or the actio aestimatoria (price reduction) under article 1427, within the short periods of article 1431. An unpaid seller of an immovable cannot ask for dissolution for non-payment (article 1438); he sues for the price instead.
Unwind the contract after judgment.
Once the contract is dissolved, each party must return what it received, so that things are restored "as though the obligation had never been contracted" (article 1066). Agree in writing how and when goods, keys or documents will be handed back and money refunded; if the defendant does not pay, enforce the judgment through the executive warrants in Cap. 12 (for example a garnishee order on bank accounts). Where a promise of sale was secured by earnest (caparra), each party may recede: the one who gave it forfeits it and the one who received it returns double (article 1359), unless the parties agreed otherwise. Keep the judgment and the evidence of restitution with your records, as you may need them for tax or insurance purposes.
What to watch out for
- Treating the contract as terminated by your own letter when there is no express resolutive clause: without one, only the court can dissolve the contract (article 1068), and walking away can make you the party in breach.
- Waiting too long when the contract was obtained by error, fraud or violence: the action for rescission is barred after two years (article 1222), counted from discovery of the defect.
- Missing the very short periods for defective goods: six months from delivery for movables and one year from the contract for immovables (article 1431), unless the defect could not be discovered earlier.
- Claiming more than a penalty clause allows: where the contract fixes the damages for breach, the court cannot award a greater or lesser sum (article 1138).
- Asking for dissolution while refusing to give back what you received: restitution is mutual (article 1066) and a claimant who keeps the goods or the deposit weakens the case.
- Paying in cash without receipts or agreeing important changes only orally: the claimant must prove the contract, its terms and the payments.
- Choosing the wrong court: the Small Claims Tribunal only hears money claims up to €5,000 and cases on ownership of immovables are excluded from both the Tribunal and the Court of Magistrates.
- Ignoring the debtor's defence of force majeure: a debtor who proves irresistible force or a fortuitous event is not liable in damages (article 1134), although dissolution may still be available.
Legal basis
Frequently asked questions
Can I cancel a contract in Malta if the other party breaches it?
Yes, but usually not by yourself. Every bilateral contract contains an implied resolutive condition for non-performance, so you can ask the court to dissolve it and claim damages (articles 1068 and 1069 Cap. 16). Unless the contract has an express resolutive clause, the dissolution is pronounced by the court, which may first give the other party a reasonable time to perform.
What is the difference between an express and an implied resolutive condition?
An express resolutive condition is written into the contract; when the event happens, the contract is dissolved ipso jure and the court cannot grant the defaulting party extra time (article 1067). The implied condition exists in every bilateral contract by law; it does not operate automatically and the court may allow a period of grace (article 1068).
Do I have to send a judicial letter before suing?
If the contract fixes a date for performance, the debtor is in default once that date passes (article 1130(1)). If no date is fixed, he is only put in default by an intimation through a judicial act (article 1130(2)), normally a judicial letter or protest. Even when not strictly required, a judicial letter is useful evidence and interrupts prescription.
Can I get my deposit back if the builder never finished the work?
If the contractor failed to perform, you can ask the court to dissolve the contract and order the return of what you paid, with damages (articles 1066 and 1069). You may instead ask to be authorised to have the work completed by someone else at the contractor's expense (article 1127). Keep proof of payments and photographs of the unfinished work.
How long do I have to rescind a contract signed because of fraud or a mistake?
Two years. The action for rescission on the ground of error, fraud or violence is barred on the expiration of two years (article 1222 Cap. 16), running from the day the error or fraud was discovered or the violence ceased (article 1223). Fraud is not presumed and must be proved by the party alleging it (article 981).
What damages can I claim for breach of contract in Malta?
The loss you actually suffered and the profit you were deprived of (article 1135), limited to what could be foreseen when the contract was made unless the other party acted fraudulently (article 1136). If the contract sets a penalty sum, the court awards exactly that (article 1138). For unpaid money the damages are interest at 8% a year (article 1139).
Which court deals with a contract dispute in Malta?
Money claims up to €5,000 can go to the Small Claims Tribunal (Cap. 380). Claims up to €15,000 against persons living in Malta are heard by the Court of Magistrates (article 47 Cap. 12), and larger claims by the Civil Court, First Hall. Disputes about ownership of immovable property are excluded from the Magistrates' jurisdiction regardless of value.
The seller delivered goods that are different from what I ordered. What can I do?
If the goods are not of the quality promised or do not match the sample, you may reject them and claim damages, or keep them with a price reduction set by experts (article 1390). For hidden defects you have the actio redhibitoria or aestimatoria (article 1427), but only within six months of delivery for movables (article 1431). Consumers also have the legal guarantee rules.
Can I withdraw from an online purchase without giving a reason?
That is a separate consumer right: for most distance contracts you have 14 days to withdraw without giving reasons, under the consumer rights rules derived from the Consumer Affairs Act. It does not depend on any breach by the trader. See our guide on the cooling-off period for online purchases in Malta.
What happens to the earnest (caparra) paid on a promise of sale?
Where earnest was given on a promise to sell, each party may recede from the promise: the party who gave the earnest forfeits it, and the party who received it must return double (article 1359 Cap. 16), unless a different usage applies. If the promise was not honoured because of a breach, damages may also be claimed under the general rules.
Practical legal guides
Analyse my document →Legal guideContract templatesCountry home page