Moral damages in Malta: when you can claim them and how much
Maltese civil law has traditionally been reluctant to put a price on pain, distress, humiliation or anxiety. The general rule in article 1045 of the Civil Code limits compensation in tort to actual loss, expenses, loss of wages and loss of future earnings. Moral harm is recoverable only where the law expressly allows it, and there are three main routes. First, the proviso to article 1045(1), which allows moral and psychological harm of up to €10,000 where the damage arises from certain wilful crimes. Second, the Media and Defamation Act (Cap. 579), which allows moral damages of up to €11,640 for libel and €5,000 for slander. Third, proceedings for breach of fundamental rights under the European Convention Act (Cap. 319) and article 46 of the Constitution, where the Civil Court, First Hall, in its constitutional jurisdiction may grant any redress it considers appropriate. This guide is for victims of violent or sexual crimes, people whose reputation has been attacked in the media or online, and people whose rights were breached by a public authority. It explains which route fits your case, which court to go to, how the amounts are assessed and which time limits can make the claim lapse. For ordinary material loss (repairs, medical bills, lost wages) see our guide on claiming damages in Malta; this page deals only with the non-pecuniary part.
Key facts
Deadline
A claim for moral harm under article 1045 arises from a criminal offence, so it prescribes together with the criminal action under article 688 of the Criminal Code (article 2154(1) of the Civil Code); other actions for damages are barred after two years (article 2153). A libel or slander action under Cap. 579 is barred one year from the date of publication (article 18). Compensation for a wrongful conviction under article 4A of Cap. 319 must be claimed within six months of the reversal of the conviction or the pardon. Constitutional redress has no fixed statutory period in Cap. 319, but delay weighs against the applicant.
What to do
Identify the legal basis before anything else. Under article 1045(1) of the Civil Code, damages in tort consist of actual loss, expenses, lost wages and loss of future earnings caused by permanent incapacity. Distress, grief or humiliation are not on that list, and a claim for moral damages that rests only on articles 1031 to 1033 will be dismissed for that part.
Ask yourself which of the three routes applies: (1) the harm was caused by a wilful crime against your dignity or person; (2) your reputation was harmed by a statement published or spoken by someone else; (3) a public authority breached a fundamental right. If none applies, your claim is limited to material loss, even if the suffering was real. A lawyer can tell you within one consultation whether a special law gives you more.
If the harm comes from a crime, check whether it qualifies under the proviso to article 1045(1). Moral and psychological harm is recoverable only where the damage arises from a criminal offence other than an involuntary one, and only for crimes affecting the dignity of persons under Title VII of Part II of Book First of the Criminal Code, or wilful crimes against the person punishable with at least three years' imprisonment under Title VIII.
In practice this covers sexual offences, domestic violence and serious wilful bodily harm. A road accident caused by negligence does not qualify, because the offence is involuntary. The ceiling is €10,000, or such other maximum as the Minister may prescribe by regulations. Keep the police report, the charge sheet and, if available, the judgment of the criminal court, because the civil court will want proof that the offence was committed.
Decide where to claim the moral harm arising from a crime. Every offence gives rise to both a criminal and a civil action (article 3 of the Criminal Code). The criminal court can, upon conviction for a crime, order the offender to pay damages to the victim, applying the rules of article 24 of the Probation Act (article 532A of the Criminal Code). Ask the prosecuting officer or the Attorney General's office, through your lawyer, to request such an order.
If no order is made, or it does not cover all your loss, file a sworn application in the civil courts. Claims up to €15,000 against a person living in Malta go before the Court of Magistrates (article 47 of the Code of Organization and Civil Procedure); larger claims go before the Civil Court, First Hall. Moral harm and material loss can be claimed in the same action.
Collect evidence of the moral and psychological harm itself. The proviso to article 1045(1) does not give a fixed scale, so the court assesses the amount within the €10,000 ceiling on the evidence before it. Useful evidence includes reports from a psychiatrist or clinical psychologist, records of therapy sessions, medical certificates showing time off work, statements from family members about changes in behaviour, and any victim impact statement made in the criminal proceedings.
A court-appointed medical expert may examine you; attend every appointment and keep copies of your own specialist reports. Psychological harm that is not documented is very difficult to quantify, and the court will not award the maximum merely because the crime was serious. Separate the moral harm from the permanent incapacity, which is assessed under article 1045(2) as material loss.
If your reputation was attacked, use the Media and Defamation Act. Statements are actionable only if they cause or are likely to cause serious harm to your reputation (article 3(4) of Cap. 579); for a company, serious harm means serious financial loss. Libel covers written media, which includes online content, social media posts and printed material; slander covers spoken statements uttered with malice.
The court may award moral damages of up to €11,640 for libel and up to €5,000 for slander, in addition to any actual damages (article 9). The total moral damages for the same case cannot exceed €11,640 even if you sue for several statements (article 11(3)). Before filing, consider asking for a right of reply: it must be claimed within one month of publication (article 15). Our separate guide on defamation explains the defences in detail.
Prepare for how the court assesses defamation damages. Under article 11(1) of Cap. 579 the court considers the gravity and extent of the defamation, whether the defendant exercised due diligence before publishing, and whether the defendant apologised or offered a clarification. If the defendant apologised and published an unreserved correction with the same prominence before proceedings were filed, moral damages are capped at €5,000 (article 11(2)).
The court must also consider the economic capacity of the defendant and the impact of the award on the newspaper, broadcaster, website or journalist (article 11(4)). At a preliminary hearing, held within twenty days from the time allowed for the sworn reply, the court decides whether the case can be settled by mediation, agreement or apology, with damages not exceeding €1,000 (article 10). Bring a realistic settlement proposal to that hearing.
If a public authority breached your fundamental rights, consider a constitutional application. Under article 4 of the European Convention Act (Cap. 319), any person who alleges that a Convention right has been, is being or is likely to be contravened may apply to the Civil Court, First Hall, for redress. The court may make any order it considers appropriate; in practice this includes a declaration of the breach and compensation for non-pecuniary damage, for instance for excessive length of proceedings, degrading conditions of detention or interference with property.
The court may decline to exercise its powers if adequate ordinary remedies were available to you (proviso to article 4(2)), so explain why an ordinary civil action would not have been enough. The same application may also invoke articles 33 to 45 of the Constitution (article 4(7)). Either party can appeal to the Constitutional Court (article 4(4)).
Check the special rule for wrongful convictions. Where a conviction is reversed or the person is pardoned because a new fact shows a miscarriage of justice, article 4A of Cap. 319 gives a right to compensation under article 3 of the Seventh Protocol to the Convention. The maximum is €23,293.73.
Compensation is fixed by agreement with the State or, failing agreement, by the Civil Court, First Hall, on an application filed within six months of the reversal or pardon. An appeal lies to the Court of Appeal by application filed within twenty days of the decision (article 4A(3)). This is a short deadline; instruct a lawyer as soon as the criminal judgment in your favour becomes final, and keep the full record of the criminal proceedings.
Watch the time limits and interrupt prescription in time. A civil action for damages arising from a criminal offence prescribes with the criminal action under the Criminal Code (article 2154(1) of the Civil Code and article 688 of the Criminal Code), so the period depends on the punishment for the offence. Other actions for damages are barred after two years (article 2153). A defamation action is barred one year from publication (article 18 of Cap. 579), and under the single publication rule a later republication in substantially the same manner does not restart the clock (article 13(3)).
A judicial letter or the filing of proceedings interrupts prescription. Do not wait for the criminal case to end before considering the civil deadline: ask your lawyer to calculate the period on the day you first consult, and to protect it in writing if negotiations drag on.
What to watch out for
- Claiming moral damages in an ordinary negligence case. Article 1045 allows moral harm only for wilful crimes listed in the proviso; a claim for distress after a traffic accident or a medical error under the general rules will be dismissed for that part.
- Missing the one-year defamation deadline. Article 18 of Cap. 579 bars the action one year from publication; collecting screenshots for months and then filing late loses the claim entirely.
- Expecting the maximum award. The ceilings of €10,000 and €11,640 are maximums, not tariffs. Without medical or psychological evidence, or proof of the extent of publication, awards are usually well below them.
- Suing several authors of the same publication in separate cases. Article 3(3) of Cap. 579 does not allow separate actions against the author, editor and publisher for the same defamation, and the moral damages for the same case are capped overall.
- Ignoring an apology. If the defendant offered an unreserved apology and correction before proceedings, the moral damages cannot exceed €5,000 (article 11(2) of Cap. 579), and costs may be at risk if you litigate for more.
- Filing a constitutional case where an ordinary remedy exists. The Civil Court, First Hall, may decline to exercise its constitutional jurisdiction if adequate ordinary means of redress were available (proviso to article 4(2) of Cap. 319).
- Mixing material and moral loss in one undocumented figure. The court assesses lost earnings and permanent incapacity under article 1045(2) separately from moral harm; an unexplained global sum makes it easier for the defendant to challenge every item.
Legal basis
Frequently asked questions
Can I get compensation for stress and anxiety in Malta?
Only where a law expressly allows it. Under the Civil Code, moral and psychological harm is compensated only if it results from certain wilful crimes (proviso to article 1045(1)), up to €10,000. Defamation under Cap. 579 and breaches of fundamental rights under Cap. 319 are the other main routes. Stress caused by ordinary negligence or a breach of contract is generally not compensated as such.
What is the maximum moral damages award in Malta?
It depends on the route. For crimes under article 1045 of the Civil Code the ceiling is €10,000, unless the Minister prescribes a different maximum. For libel it is €11,640 and for slander €5,000 (article 9 of Cap. 579). For constitutional redress there is no statutory ceiling; the court fixes what it considers appropriate.
Can I claim moral damages after a car accident?
Usually not. The proviso to article 1045(1) excludes involuntary offences, and a typical accident caused by negligence is involuntary. You can still claim actual loss, medical expenses, lost wages and loss of future earnings for permanent incapacity, which are assessed under article 1045(2) of the Civil Code.
Do I need a criminal conviction to claim moral damages for assault?
The civil court must be satisfied that the damage arises from a qualifying crime, so a conviction is the strongest evidence. The criminal court itself may order damages on sentence (article 532A of the Criminal Code). Without a conviction you must prove the offence in the civil proceedings, which is harder but not excluded by the text of article 1045.
How long do I have to sue for defamation in Malta?
One year from the date of publication (article 18 of the Media and Defamation Act). A right of reply must be claimed within one month of publication (article 15). If the same person keeps publishing similar statements, you must bring them into the same action rather than filing new ones (article 13(6)).
Can a company claim moral damages for defamation?
A company, foundation, co-operative or other legal person may sue for defamation (article 16(2) of Cap. 579), but harm to the reputation of a body trading for profit counts as serious only if it has caused or is likely to cause serious financial loss (article 3(4)). Trade libel carries up to €11,640 in addition to actual loss.
Which court hears a human rights claim for compensation?
The Civil Court, First Hall, in its constitutional jurisdiction, under article 4 of the European Convention Act and article 46 of the Constitution. Appeals go to the Constitutional Court. Only after exhausting these remedies can an application be lodged with the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg.
Can heirs claim moral damages if the victim died?
Article 1046 of the Civil Code allows the heirs to recover damages as for permanent total incapacity, in addition to actual loss and expenses. Whether moral harm under the proviso to article 1045(1) passes to the heirs is not stated in the article; take advice on the facts of your case.
Is the defamation award reduced if the newspaper apologised?
Yes. If the defendant apologised and published an unreserved correction, or your reply, with the same prominence before proceedings began, the moral damages cannot exceed €5,000 (article 11(2) of Cap. 579). An apology offered later is still one of the factors the court weighs under article 11(1)(c).
How much does a moral damages claim cost?
Court registry fees depend on the value of the claim under the tariffs annexed to the Code of Organization and Civil Procedure, and lawyer's fees are agreed with your advocate. The losing party is usually ordered to pay the costs. If your means are limited, you may qualify for legal aid; see our guide on legal aid in Malta.
Practical legal guides
Analyse my document →Legal guideContract templatesCountry home page