Contesting a fine before a Commissioner for Justice in Malta
Most everyday fines in Malta, for parking on a yellow line, driving in a bus lane, leaving rubbish out on the wrong day or a minor public order breach, are not criminal cases. They are scheduled offences under the Commissioners for Justice Act (Cap. 291): an act listed in the Schedule to the Act is not treated as a criminal act, but a Commissioner for Justice sitting at a Local Tribunal may find you guilty of an infringement and order you to pay a penalty (article 3(2)). Tickets are issued by the Police, by community officers working for the Local Enforcement System Agency (LESA) or by another authority entitled to enforce the law in question.
This guide is for anyone who has received a ticket or a Local Tribunal summons and believes it is wrong or too harsh, whether resident or visitor. It explains when the ticket itself is void, how to ask the Petitions Board to cancel the proceedings, how to contest the charge before the Commissioner without necessarily attending in person, what the Commissioner can order, and how to take a decision to the Court of Magistrates within thirty days. For speeding and speed cameras there is a separate guide; for clamping and towing, see the guide on vehicles that are towed or clamped.
Acting in time gives you a cancelled ticket, a lower penalty or at least a fair hearing.
Key facts
Deadline
Thirty days from the Commissioner's decision to apply to the Court of Magistrates (article 11(1) of Cap. 291) and thirty days from the Tribunal judgement at the latest to petition the Petitions Board (regulation 4(2) of S.L. 291.04); payment of the penalty alone is possible up to three days before the hearing (article 5(4)), and a penalty not paid within one month of the final decision carries an extra €11.65 (article 10(2)). Fifteen days from learning of a decision given without valid service to ask for a re-trial (article 11A(2)).
What to do
Identify who issued the ticket and under which law. The notice handed to you or fixed to your windscreen under article 14(2) of Cap. 291 must describe the offence, state the penalty, where and by when it can be paid and what happens if you do not pay. It may instead tell you how to view these details online, in which case a full notice must follow by post if you do not look them up in time (article 14(2A)).
Note the issuing body (Police, LESA, a local council or another authority), the offence code, the date, time and place, and the vehicle registration if one is involved. Photograph the place, the signs and road markings as they were on that day. Under the Traffic Signs and Carriageway Markings Regulations (S.L. 65.05) a No Parking sign only forbids leaving a vehicle stationary for more than ten minutes unless a plate shows otherwise, so the exact signage matters.
Check whether a ticket sent by post was issued properly. The rule is that the notice is handed over on the spot when the person is detected (regulation 3(1) of the Service of Notice by Mail Regulations, S.L. 291.03). It may be posted instead only where handing it over was impractical because of speeding, dangerous driving or another serious reason, because the officer was threatened or met hostile conduct, or where the act was recorded on CCTV; it must then be mailed within five working days and state all the facts and the reason why it was not handed over (regulation 3(2)–(4)).
If these steps were not followed, the notice is null ipso jure (regulation 3(5)). Compare the date of the offence with the posting date and read the notice for the stated reason. Failure to follow S.L. 291.03 is also an express ground for a petition (regulation 6(1)(e) of S.L. 291.04).
Decide whether to pay. Within the period shown on the notice, never shorter than seven days, you may pay a penalty that cannot exceed the minimum fixed by law for the offence or €23.29, whichever is higher (article 14(3) of Cap. 291). For traffic contraventions in the Second Schedule to the Traffic Regulation Ordinance (Cap. 65) the Police or a community officer may also give a notice allowing payment of the scheduled fine within ten days (article 62(3)).
Payment is deemed to be an admission of the offence (article 14(5) of Cap. 291 and article 62(5) of Cap. 65) and, once paid, no petition can be allowed (regulation 4(4) of S.L. 291.04). If you want to contest, do not pay at this stage. If you do nothing, ordinary proceedings follow (article 14(4)) and you will receive a summons to appear before the Commissioner.
Make sure the summons reaches you. A Local Tribunal summons is served personally, at your postal or last registered address (the address on your identity document) on a member of your household, or at your place of work (regulation 3 of the Local Tribunals (Delivery of Summons) Regulations, S.L. 291.01). After a second failed attempt it may be left at or fixed to the door of your last registered address and an abstract published in the Gazette or a daily newspaper; you are then deemed notified three days after publication (regulation 7).
If you have subscribed to service by email, the summons is deemed served when the email is sent (regulation 4(1) of S.L. 291.07). Keep your address on your identity document up to date and check the email address you registered with LESA. The summons states the hearing date, the penalty and the maximum additional penalty, and warns that failure to appear is treated as an admission (article 5(3)–(4) of Cap. 291).
Consider a petition to the Petitions Board. Anyone charged, about to be charged or already found guilty of a scheduled offence may ask the Board to waive or discontinue the proceedings or to remit the penalty in whole or in part (regulations 3 and 4(1) of S.L. 291.04). The petition is filed in the Registry of the Board within a reasonable time and not later than thirty days from the Tribunal judgement, and it must give reasons, under pain of nullity (regulation 4(2)–(3)).
The Board accedes only for impelling reasons, such as an evident mistake in the identity of the offender or the vehicle, an evident mistake leading to a wrong finding of guilt, humanitarian reasons, a charge that is manifestly unjust or oppressive, or failure to follow the postal notice procedure (regulation 6(1)). Attach evidence: photos, a hire contract, a medical certificate, proof that the car was sold. Filing suspends the Tribunal proceedings and prescription until the Board decides (regulation 6(2)).
Follow the petition timetable. The Board must acknowledge the petition within three working days and forward it to LESA or the Police, who have three weeks to comment; the Board then decides within fifteen days of receiving the comments, or immediately if no comments arrive in time, and the Registry communicates the decision within five working days (regulation 5(2)–(5) of S.L. 291.04).
If the petition is accepted, the proceedings are extinguished or the penalty is no longer recoverable (regulation 7). If it is refused, a new summons is issued (regulation 6(2)(c)) and you can still contest the charge before the Commissioner. A refused petition is not the end of the matter: it only means that the case goes to a hearing.
Contest the charge before the Commissioner. You may attend in person, appoint a representative in writing who has the same rights as you (article 8 of Cap. 291), or send written representations or a sworn declaration on the facts to the Registry instead of attending; the Commissioner must take them into account as if you had made them orally (article 7). The Commissioner applies the procedure of the Court of Magistrates under the Criminal Code (article 8) and can hear witnesses on oath (article 3(1)(b)).
Be ready on the first day: the Commissioner is to decide every case on the first day of hearing and grants a postponement only exceptionally (article 14(9)), and you will not be notified of a new date if the case is put off; checking it is your responsibility (article 14(4)(b)). Data from electronic devices is proof of its contents unless you prove otherwise, and photographs or video must be authenticated by their author (article 14(6)–(7)). Ask for that authentication if it is missing.
Know what the Commissioner can decide. If the Commissioner finds the offence not proved, you cannot be charged again for it before a Commissioner or any court (article 10(1) of Cap. 291). If found guilty, you are ordered to pay a penalty up to the maximum fine for the offence and, where the law so provides, the Commissioner must also order forfeiture or suspension of a licence (article 10(2)). Expenses incurred by a public authority to remedy the consequences may be added up to €2,329.37 (article 10(4)).
If the penalty is not paid within one month of the final decision, a further €11.65 becomes due (article 10(2), proviso). The order is an executive title enforceable like a civil judgement (article 10(5)), and while a traffic penalty remains unpaid Transport Malta must withhold renewal of the vehicle's road licence (article 56 of Cap. 65). The debt does not pass to your heirs (article 10(6) of Cap. 291).
Apply to the Court of Magistrates if the decision is wrong. Within thirty days of the Commissioner's decision you may apply to the Court of Magistrates to have it revoked or varied; the court then decides the merits under the Criminal Code and its decision cannot be appealed further (article 11(1)–(2) of Cap. 291). A frivolous or vexatious application can cost up to €116.47 in addition (article 11(3)).
If you were found guilty without ever being duly served, apply instead for a re-trial within fifteen days from the day you learned, or should reasonably have learned, of the decision (article 11A). Proof of absence abroad, a change of address registered on your identity document before the service date, or a certificate of notification with obvious errors helps here; the certificate is otherwise proof of its contents (regulation 15 of S.L. 291.01).
What to watch out for
- Paying "to get rid of it" when you plan to contest. Payment is an admission (article 14(5) of Cap. 291) and bars a petition (regulation 4(4) of S.L. 291.04). Only non-habitual residents paying an on-the-spot fine keep their right to contest, because their payment counts as a deposit (regulation 4(4) of S.L. 291.10).
- Ignoring the summons. Non-appearance without written representations is treated as an admission and the Commissioner orders payment in your absence (article 7 of Cap. 291).
- An outdated address on your identity document. Service at your last registered address and publication in the Gazette are valid even if you no longer live there (regulation 7 of S.L. 291.01), and the re-trial deadline is only fifteen days.
- Not checking a postponed hearing date. No notice of adjournment is sent (article 14(4)(b) of Cap. 291); missing the new date has the same effect as not appearing.
- A petition without reasons, or filed late. It is null if it does not state reasons (regulation 4(3) of S.L. 291.04) and cannot be filed later than thirty days after the Tribunal judgement.
- Relying on a technical defect alone. Proceedings are not invalid for non-observance of formalities if there was substantial compliance and natural justice was observed (article 14(8) of Cap. 291); the postal notice rule in S.L. 291.03 is an exception because it expressly makes the notice null.
- Owners lending or selling a car without paperwork. For traffic contraventions in the Second Schedule to Cap. 65, the owner, registered user or hirer is responsible unless the driver is named and admits or is found guilty, or the vehicle was used without permission (article 55(3) of Cap. 65).
Legal basis
Frequently asked questions
How do I appeal a LESA fine in Malta?
There is no separate LESA appeal. You either petition the Petitions Board, which can waive the proceedings or remit the penalty for reasons such as mistaken identity or humanitarian grounds (regulations 4 and 6 of S.L. 291.04), or you contest the charge before a Commissioner for Justice at the Local Tribunal. A Commissioner's decision can then be taken to the Court of Magistrates within thirty days (article 11 of Cap. 291).
Do I have to attend the Local Tribunal in person?
No. You may appoint a representative in writing, who has the same rights as you (article 8 of Cap. 291), or send written representations or a sworn declaration on the facts to the Registry; the Commissioner must consider them as if you had spoken at the hearing (article 7). If you neither attend nor write, you are deemed to have admitted the charge.
What happens if I do not pay a contravention in Malta?
The case goes to a Commissioner, who can order a penalty up to the maximum fine for the offence (article 10(2) of Cap. 291). If that penalty is not paid within one month of the final decision, €11.65 is added; the order can be enforced like a civil judgement (article 10(5)), and for traffic offences the vehicle's road licence will not be renewed until you pay (article 56 of Cap. 65).
Is a ticket received by post valid?
Only in limited cases. The notice should be handed over on the spot; it may be posted only for serious reasons such as speeding or dangerous driving, hostility towards the officer, or a CCTV recording, and must be mailed within five working days with the reason stated. Otherwise it is null ipso jure (regulation 3 of S.L. 291.03), which you can raise before the Commissioner or in a petition.
Can I still petition after paying the fine?
No. Regulation 4(4) of S.L. 291.04 bars any petition once the financial penalty has been paid, and payment counts as an admission (article 14(5) of Cap. 291). The exception is an on-the-spot fine paid by a non-habitual resident under S.L. 291.10, which is treated as a deposit until the Board or a Commissioner decides, and is refunded if the fine is overturned.
Can a tourist be fined on the spot in Malta?
Yes. Since July 2026, a person who is not Maltese and has no Maltese residence document can be required to pay a scheduled offence fine immediately, electronically and not in cash (regulations 4 and 5 of S.L. 291.10). If they refuse, the Police may hold their travel document until payment or the end of the proceedings (regulation 6). A petition decided within 48 hours remains possible.
Is there a time limit for the authorities to charge me?
Criminal action for contraventions is generally time-barred after three months (article 688(f) of the Criminal Code), and article 12 of Cap. 291 applies the same prescription to proceedings before a Commissioner. Service of the summons suspends prescription for six months and a pending petition also suspends it. Work out the dates carefully before relying on prescription at the hearing.
I was found guilty but never received a summons. What can I do?
Apply to the Court of Magistrates for a re-trial on the ground that you were never duly served. You must file within fifteen days from the day you learned, or should reasonably have learned, of the decision (article 11A of Cap. 291). Bring evidence that the service was defective, since the certificate of notification is proof of its contents unless shown otherwise (regulation 15 of S.L. 291.01).
Practical legal guides
Analyse my document →Legal guideContract templatesCountry home page