Suspended sentence and probation in Malta: conditions and risks
A Maltese court that finds a person guilty does not always send him to prison. Under article 28A of the Criminal Code (Cap. 9), a sentence of imprisonment of up to two years may be suspended for an operational period of one to four years: the sentence is passed, but it only takes effect if the offender commits another offence punishable with imprisonment during that period. Alongside it, the Probation Act (Cap. 446) gives the courts probation orders, community service orders, combination orders and absolute or conditional discharge, which are imposed instead of a sentence.
This guide is for anyone facing sentence in the Court of Magistrates or the Criminal Court, for families of accused persons and for victims who want to know whether compensation will actually be paid. It explains when each measure is available, what the court can attach to it (supervision, unpaid work, restitution within six months), what happens on a breach or a new offence, and how these measures appear on a conduct certificate (kondotta). The practical outcome is a clear view of what to ask the court for, what you are agreeing to, and which mistakes turn a suspended sentence into real imprisonment.
Key facts
Deadline
The operational period of a suspended sentence lasts at least one and at most four years from the order (art. 28A(1) Cap. 9); a probation order lasts one to three years and conditional discharge up to three years (arts 7 and 22 Cap. 446). Restitution or compensation ordered with a suspended sentence must be paid within the time fixed by the court, at most six months (art. 28H(2)). An appeal from the Court of Magistrates must be filed within 12 working days (art. 417 Cap. 9).
What to do
Understand the conditions for a suspended sentence.
Article 28A(1) Cap. 9 allows suspension only of a sentence of imprisonment of not more than two years; where several crimes are punished with a single term, that term must not exceed two years (art. 28E(1)). The court must first be satisfied that imprisonment would have been the right sentence without the power to suspend (art. 28A(2)), so a suspended sentence is not a lighter alternative to a fine. Suspension is excluded if you are already serving a prison sentence, if you are a recidivist within article 50 (a further crime within five years, or ten years after a sentence of over five years), or if the offence was committed during probation or conditional discharge (art. 28A(7)). Imprisonment in default of paying a fine cannot be suspended (art. 28A(6)).
Ask early for a pre-sentencing report.
Under article 6 of the Probation Act the court may commission the Department of Probation Services to prepare a pre-sentencing report before deciding between imprisonment, a suspended sentence with supervision, or a probation order. Except in summary proceedings before the Court of Magistrates, the report is compulsory before dealing with an offender under 18 for an offence punishable by imprisonment, and before any community service or combination order. A probation officer examines your personal and social circumstances, work, family and any addiction, and you and the prosecution receive a copy (art. 6(5)). Cooperate fully: missing appointments or giving incomplete information often leads the court to choose imprisonment. Your advocate can ask for an adjournment so that the report can be prepared (art. 6(3)).
Know the alternatives under the Probation Act.
A probation order places you under a probation officer's supervision for one to three years instead of a sentence (art. 7(1) Cap. 446); it is available for offences punishable with up to seven years, or up to ten years if the court states special reasons (art. 7(2)). A community service order requires 40 to 480 hours of unpaid work, for offenders aged 16 or over who agree and sign the work agreement (art. 11), to be completed within one month to two years (art. 14). A combination order joins probation with 40 to 100 hours of work (art. 18). Where punishment is inexpedient, the court may discharge you absolutely or on condition of committing no offence for up to three years (art. 22). From 14 years of age, probation requires your consent (art. 7(7)).
Check the conditions attached to the order before you accept them.
If the suspended prison term exceeds six months, the court may add a supervision order, placing you under a probation officer for up to the operational period, and may also add community service (art. 28G Cap. 9). A probation order may require residence at a specified address or institution, treatment for drug addiction or a mental condition, or weekend attendance at an approved residential institution for up to six weeks (art. 7(3)–(6) Cap. 446). The court may also restrict travel outside Malta (art. 20A). The court must explain these requirements in ordinary language (art. 28A(4) Cap. 9, art. 7(7) Cap. 446). If you work abroad, travel regularly or cannot attend treatment, say so before the order is made; changes later require a court application (art. 10).
Pay restitution or compensation on time.
When it suspends a sentence, the court may order you to return what was taken or to pay compensation to the victim, including in certain crimes against the person moral or psychological harm up to €10,000 (art. 28H(1) Cap. 9). It fixes a time limit of no more than six months and may allow instalments (art. 28H(2)–(3)). If you do not pay, the victim may file a sworn application; the court hears the parties within seven days of service and, if it finds non-compliance, orders the suspended sentence to take effect, although it may grant one further peremptory month for reasonable cause (art. 28H(5)–(6)). The victim must apply within three months after the deadline expires (art. 28H(7)). Under probation or discharge, compensation ordered under article 24 Cap. 446 is enforced like a civil judgment.
Comply with supervision and community service.
Under a supervision order you must keep in touch with the supervising officer as instructed and notify any change of address (art. 28G(3) Cap. 9). On the officer's written report, the court may, in serious or repeated cases, activate the suspended sentence, or impose a fine of up to €232.94 while the order continues (art. 28G(9)). Under the Probation Act, a breach of any requirement can lead to the same fine or to being sentenced for the original offence as if just convicted (art. 21(2) Cap. 446); the information must be filed within three months of the breach and the court hears it within 20 days (art. 21(1)). The probation officer reports to the court at least every six months (art. 8(1)), so missed appointments will reach the court.
Avoid any new offence during the operational period.
If you are convicted of an offence punishable with imprisonment committed during the operational period, the court competent under article 28C must order the suspended sentence to take effect (art. 28B(1) Cap. 9). It may refrain, or extend the operational period up to four years from that date, only if the new offence was involuntary or activation would be unjust, and it must give reasons (art. 28B(2)). The court cannot reduce the suspended term (art. 28E(5)), and you are treated as a recidivist when sentenced for the new offence (art. 28F). Under probation or conditional discharge, a new conviction allows the court to sentence you for the original offence (art. 23 Cap. 446). An involuntary offence, such as causing injury through negligent driving, gives the court discretion; an intentional one usually does not.
Decide quickly on an appeal.
An appeal from a judgment of the Court of Magistrates must be filed within 12 working days from delivery, by an application signed by an advocate (arts 417(1) and 419 Cap. 9); a person placed on probation or discharged may appeal against the conviction within the same time (art. 417(2)). Appeals from the Criminal Court are filed within 15 working days (art. 504). An order activating a suspended sentence is treated as a sentence and is appealable, but there is no appeal on the length of the operational period, on its variation, or on the restitution or compensation direction (art. 28I). Note that the Attorney General may appeal a sentence he considers unduly lenient where articles 28A–28H or the Probation Act were applied, for offences punishable with more than two years (art. 500(3)).
Check what appears on your conduct certificate.
Under article 5(d) of the Conduct Certificates Ordinance (Cap. 77), an order made under the Probation Act, and a suspended sentence that has not taken effect, are not entered in the conduct certificate issued by the Department of Justice. In addition, a conviction followed by probation, community service, a combination order or discharge is deemed not to be a conviction for most purposes and is disregarded for laws imposing disqualifications on convicted persons (art. 25 Cap. 446), with exceptions such as disciplinary proceedings against public officers. Be aware that disqualifications and forfeitures ordered with a suspended sentence still apply (art. 28A(5) Cap. 9), so a suspended sentence for drink driving may still be accompanied by a driving disqualification. If a suspended sentence is activated, the conviction is recorded.
What to watch out for
- Treating a suspended sentence as an acquittal. It is a real sentence of imprisonment which takes effect automatically on a later conviction for an offence punishable with imprisonment (art. 28B(1) Cap. 9).
- Not paying the compensation fixed under article 28H Cap. 9 within the deadline. The victim's sworn application can lead to activation of the full prison term after a hearing within seven days.
- Agreeing to probation conditions you cannot keep, such as residence, treatment or weekend attendance, and then missing appointments; a breach can lead to being sentenced for the original offence (art. 21(2) Cap. 446).
- Moving house or leaving Malta without telling the supervising officer or ignoring a travel restriction under article 20A Cap. 446.
- Assuming a suspended sentence removes other penalties. Disqualifications, cancellations and forfeitures ordered with it remain in force (art. 28A(5) Cap. 9).
- Missing the 12 working days for an appeal from the Court of Magistrates (art. 417 Cap. 9), or appealing only the operational period or compensation direction, which article 28I excludes.
- Not considering the Attorney General's right to appeal an unduly lenient sentence under article 500(3) Cap. 9 when deciding whether to appeal yourself.
Legal basis
Frequently asked questions
What is a suspended sentence in Malta?
It is a prison sentence of up to two years which the court orders not to take effect unless, during an operational period of one to four years, you commit another offence punishable with imprisonment and a court then orders the original sentence to take effect (art. 28A(1) Cap. 9). It is a sentence, not an acquittal, and the court must first consider that imprisonment would otherwise have been appropriate.
Can a suspended sentence be given for any offence?
Only where the prison term imposed does not exceed two years. It is excluded if you are already serving a prison sentence, if you are a recidivist under article 50, or if the offence was committed during probation or conditional discharge (art. 28A(7) Cap. 9). Imprisonment in default of a fine cannot be suspended (art. 28A(6)).
What happens if I commit another offence during a suspended sentence?
If convicted of an offence punishable with imprisonment committed during the operational period, the court must order the suspended sentence to take effect (art. 28B(1) Cap. 9). Only if the new offence was involuntary, or activation would be unjust, may it refrain or extend the period up to four years, giving reasons. The suspended term cannot be reduced (art. 28E(5)).
Does a suspended sentence appear on my conduct certificate?
Not while it has not taken effect. Article 5(d) of the Conduct Certificates Ordinance (Cap. 77) excludes from the certificate a suspended sentence that has not taken effect and orders under the Probation Act. If the sentence is later activated, the conviction is recorded. The court may also, on application, order non-registration in certain cases (art. 8 Cap. 77).
What is the difference between probation and a suspended sentence?
With a suspended sentence the court passes a prison term and suspends it (art. 28A Cap. 9). With probation it does not sentence you at all, but places you under a probation officer for one to three years (art. 7 Cap. 446). A breach of probation or a new offence allows the court to sentence you for the original offence (arts 21 and 23).
How many hours of community service can a Maltese court order?
Between 40 and 480 hours of unpaid work, for offenders aged 16 or over who consent and sign the community service work agreement (art. 11 Cap. 446). The work must be done within one month to two years from the order, which the court may extend (art. 14). A combination order adds 40 to 100 hours to probation supervision (art. 18).
Do I have to agree to a probation order?
If you are 14 or older, yes: the court explains the order and its requirements in ordinary language and may not make it unless you express willingness to comply (art. 7(7) Cap. 446). A community service order likewise requires your agreement and signature (art. 11(3)). Refusing usually means the court will impose another sentence, possibly imprisonment.
What if I cannot pay the compensation ordered with a suspended sentence?
Ask the court for instalments when the order is made (art. 28H(3) Cap. 9). If you later fail to pay, the victim may apply on oath; at the hearing the court may grant a further peremptory month for reasonable cause, but otherwise must order the sentence to take effect (art. 28H(5)–(6)). Pay what you can and keep proof of each payment.
Can I appeal against a suspended sentence in Malta?
Yes, against conviction and sentence, within 12 working days of a Court of Magistrates judgment (art. 417 Cap. 9) or 15 working days of a Criminal Court decision (art. 504). There is no appeal on the length of the operational period, its variation, or the compensation direction (art. 28I(2)). The Attorney General may also appeal an unduly lenient sentence (art. 500(3)).
Is a probation order a criminal conviction?
A conviction followed by probation, community service, a combination order or discharge is deemed not to be a conviction for any purpose other than those proceedings and, for public officers, disciplinary matters (art. 25(1) Cap. 446). It is disregarded for laws imposing disqualifications on convicted persons (art. 25(2)). If you are later sentenced for that offence as an adult, this protection ends.
Practical legal guides
Analyse my document →Legal guideContract templatesCountry home page