Faulty goods in Ireland: guarantee or your legal rights?
When something you bought breaks, the first question is usually "is it still under guarantee?". In Irish law that is the wrong starting point. Since 29 November 2022 the Consumer Rights Act 2022 gives every consumer statutory rights against the trader who sold the goods: the goods must conform to the contract, and if they do not you are entitled, free of charge, to a refund within 30 days, a repair or replacement, and in the end a price reduction or a full refund. A manufacturer's or shop's guarantee (the Act calls it a "commercial guarantee") is an extra promise on top of those rights and can never cut them down. This guide explains how the two fit together: what your statutory rights are and how long they last, when a guarantee helps you more than the law, what a valid guarantee statement must contain, who is liable for a manufacturer's guarantee, and how to use both when a trader tells you that "the warranty has expired" or sends you to the manufacturer. It applies to goods bought from a business for private use, in a shop or online, including goods received as a gift. Disputes over a complaint that has already been rejected are covered in a separate guide.
Key facts
Deadline
The short-term right to terminate and get a full refund lasts 30 days from delivery, or from installation if the trader installs the goods (s. 24 of the Consumer Rights Act 2022). A fault that appears within 12 months of delivery is presumed to have existed at delivery unless the trader proves otherwise (s. 22). After a termination, the trader must refund you within 14 days of receiving the goods back (s. 31). A court claim for breach of contract must be issued within 6 years (s. 11 of the Statute of Limitations 1957). A commercial guarantee runs for whatever period its statement specifies.
What to do
- Work out which rules apply. The Consumer Rights Act 2022 covers goods bought from a trader for purposes outside your business, after 29 November 2022. For earlier purchases the Sale of Goods and Supply of Services Act 1980 still applies, with similar rights to goods of merchantable quality. Find your receipt, order confirmation or bank statement and note the date of delivery: this is the "relevant time" from which all statutory deadlines run (s. 15(4)). If the goods were a present, you have the same rights as the buyer (s. 46), although the trader may ask for proof of purchase. Goods bought privately from another individual are outside the Act.
- Separate the legal guarantee from the commercial one. Your statutory rights are owed by the trader who sold you the goods, cost you nothing and cannot be excluded or restricted by any term or notice (s. 39). A commercial guarantee is a voluntary promise by the manufacturer, the shop or another guarantor, for example a 2-year manufacturer's warranty or a 5-year durability guarantee. It binds the guarantor on the terms of the guarantee statement and of any advertising available when you bought, and if the advertising was more generous, the advertising wins (s. 40). Read the guarantee to see whether it covers more than the law, such as accidental damage or a longer period.
- Check the guarantee statement. Where a commercial guarantee is given, the statement must be provided on a durable medium no later than delivery and must say clearly that you are entitled by law to free remedies from the trader which the guarantee does not affect; it must also give the guarantor's name and address, the procedure for claims, the goods covered and the conditions (s. 44). A guarantee cannot limit your legal rights, impose extra obligations on you or make the guarantor the sole judge of whether goods are faulty; such terms do not bind you and giving them is an offence (s. 45). A missing or defective statement does not release the guarantor from the guarantee.
- Act within 30 days if you want your money back. If the goods do not conform to the contract at delivery, you may exercise the short-term right to terminate within 30 days from delivery or installation (ss. 23 and 24). Perishable goods have a shorter period, but the trader must prove it. Tell the trader clearly, preferably in writing, that you are terminating the contract because the goods are faulty, and return them at the trader's expense (s. 28). The trader must refund the full price and your return costs within 14 days of receiving the goods, using the same means of payment and without any fee (ss. 30 and 31). A credit note is not a refund.
- After 30 days, ask the trader for a repair or replacement. You choose between the two unless your choice is impossible or disproportionately costly compared with the alternative (s. 23(2)). The trader must carry out the remedy free of charge, within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience, collect the goods at its own expense and, for installed goods, cover removal and reinstallation (s. 25). You do not pay for normal use before a replacement. For faults that appear within 12 months of delivery, you only need to show the fault and when it appeared; the trader must prove the goods were fine at delivery (s. 22). Keep copies of all correspondence.
- Use the guarantee where it gives you more. A guarantee is useful when the fault appears late, when the trader has closed down, or when it covers things the law does not, such as wear parts or accidental damage. If the shop handed you a manufacturer's guarantee, the shop is liable for it as if it were the guarantor unless it said otherwise when giving it (s. 41). A guarantee also passes to a later owner of the goods during its term (s. 42). If the guarantor fails to honour it, you can sue the guarantor for damages as for a breach of warranty (s. 43). Nothing stops you pursuing the trader and the guarantor at the same time.
- Escalate to a price reduction or final termination. If the trader refuses or fails to repair or replace, if the same or a new fault appears after a repair, if the fault is so serious that you cannot trust the trader to fix it, or if the trader makes clear it will not act in reasonable time, you may claim a proportionate price reduction or terminate the contract (s. 26). Final termination is not available for minor faults, but the trader must prove that the fault is minor. On final termination, the refund may be reduced only for depreciation beyond normal use, again proved by the trader (s. 30(3)). If part of the price is still unpaid, you may withhold a proportionate amount (s. 32).
- Challenge misleading answers. Statements such as "the guarantee has expired, so there is nothing we can do" or "you must deal with the manufacturer" misstate your rights. Giving false or misleading information about the legal rights of a consumer, or about when and how they can be exercised, is a misleading commercial practice under s. 43(3)(j) of the Consumer Protection Act 2007. Quote the sections in a final written demand giving 7 to 14 days to comply, and report the trader to the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission, which enforces both Acts. For cross-border purchases within the EU, European Consumer Centre Ireland can contact the trader on your behalf.
- Bring a claim if the trader will not move. For modest amounts the District Court small claims procedure is designed for consumers without a solicitor; the limit and fee should be checked on the Courts Service website before filing. Larger claims go to the District Court (up to €15,000) or Circuit Court (s. 14 of the Courts and Civil Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2013). Issue the claim in the correct court area, where the contract was made or the trader carries on business, as [2026] IEHC 352 illustrates. You have 6 years from the breach to sue in contract (s. 11 of the Statute of Limitations 1957), but evidence weakens with time, so act early.
What to watch out for
- Accepting "out of warranty" as the end of the matter. The statutory rights do not end when the manufacturer's guarantee does; the question is whether the goods conformed to the contract at delivery, taking into account the durability a consumer can reasonably expect for goods of that kind (s. 18).
- Missing the 30-day window. After 30 days you normally cannot insist on a refund straight away and must first allow a repair or replacement.
- Sending goods to the manufacturer at your own cost. The trader must bear collection and return costs for repairs, replacements and terminations; paying them yourself makes them harder to recover.
- Signing a guarantee registration or repair form that says the guarantor decides whether goods are faulty. Such a term is not binding (s. 45), but contesting it later costs time.
- Buying an extended warranty under pressure at the till. It is a separate paid product; check whether it adds anything to the statutory rights you already have free of charge.
- Accepting a credit note or voucher when you are entitled to a refund. Once accepted, it is hard to argue later that you wanted your money back.
- Not keeping evidence. Photos of the fault, the date it appeared and all emails are what make the 12-month presumption work in your favour.
Legal basis
Related court decisions
Frequently asked questions
Is a warranty the same as my consumer rights in Ireland?
No. Your consumer rights come from the Consumer Rights Act 2022, are owed by the trader who sold you the goods and are free. A warranty or guarantee is an additional commercial promise by the manufacturer or the shop. It must state that your legal rights are not affected and it can never reduce them (ss. 44 and 45).
The guarantee has expired. Do I still have rights?
Possibly, yes. The trader is liable for any lack of conformity that existed at delivery, and goods must have the durability normal for goods of that type, taking account of price, maintenance and any public statements about durability (s. 18). Time limits come from the Statute of Limitations 1957, which allows 6 years for a contract claim. The older the goods, the harder it is to prove the fault was there from the start.
Can I get a refund for faulty goods after 30 days?
Not immediately. After 30 days the first remedy is repair or replacement. You can claim a refund (final termination) or a price reduction if the trader refuses or fails to fix the goods, if the fault comes back, if it is serious, or if the trader will not act within a reasonable time (s. 26 of the Consumer Rights Act 2022).
Does the shop have to deal with a faulty item, or can it send me to the manufacturer?
Your statutory rights are against the shop that sold you the goods, so it cannot refuse on the ground that you should contact the manufacturer. If the shop handed you the manufacturer's guarantee, it is also liable for that guarantee unless it expressly said otherwise at the time (s. 41).
Who has to prove the fault?
If the fault becomes apparent within 12 months of delivery, it is presumed to have existed at delivery. You only need to show that the goods are faulty and when the fault appeared; the trader must then prove otherwise (s. 22). After 12 months, you need evidence that the defect was present from the start, such as an expert report.
Do I have to pay postage to return faulty goods?
No. When you terminate the contract the goods are returned at the trader's expense and the refund includes your return costs (ss. 28 and 30). For repairs and replacements the trader must take back the goods at its own expense (s. 25). Keep receipts for any postage you pay so you can claim it back.
How long does the shop have to repair my item?
A reasonable time, which the Act defines as the shortest time necessary, judged by the nature and complexity of the goods, the seriousness of the fault and the work involved (s. 25(3)). If the repair is not completed in that time, you can move on to a price reduction or final termination under s. 26.
Can I use a guarantee if I received the item as a gift?
Yes. A person who receives goods as a gift can exercise all statutory rights and remedies on the same terms as the buyer (s. 46), and a commercial guarantee passes to a later consumer who acquires the goods during its term (s. 42). You will usually need a gift receipt or other proof of purchase.
Is it illegal for a shop to say I have no rights after the warranty?
Giving false or misleading information about the legal rights of a consumer, or when and how they can be exercised, is a misleading commercial practice under s. 43 of the Consumer Protection Act 2007. You can report it to the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission, which can investigate and take enforcement action.
Does the Consumer Rights Act cover second-hand goods?
Yes, when they are sold by a trader. Conformity is judged against what a reasonable consumer would expect of second-hand goods of that age, price and description. Goods bought from a private seller are not covered by the Act; such disputes are resolved under the general law of contract.
Practical legal guides
Analyse my document →Legal guideContract templatesCountry home page