Revoking a donation in Malta: ingratitude, conditions and deadlines
Under Maltese law a donation inter vivos is a contract by which the donor irrevocably and gratuitously transfers a thing to the donee who accepts it (article 1737 of the Civil Code). Irrevocability is the rule: a clause by which the donor keeps the power to take the gift back at will makes the donation void. Parents who donate a flat to a child, or relatives who transfer land and later fall out with the recipient, are often surprised to learn how narrow the exits are. Article 1785 allows revocation only in two situations: by virtue of a resolutive condition, express or implied, and for ingratitude in the three cases listed in article 1787. Maltese law does not revoke a donation because the donor later has children. Separately, a donation can be set aside for defects of consent, or reduced after the donor's death if it eats into the reserved portion of the heirs. This guide is for donors who want a gift back, donees who are threatened with revocation, and heirs who believe a lifetime gift has disinherited them. It explains the formal requirements of a valid donation, the grounds and deadlines for revocation, the court procedure, and what happens if the donee has already sold or mortgaged the property.
Key facts
Deadline
An action for revocation on the ground of ingratitude must be brought within one year from the day of the offence, or from the day on which the donor could have become aware of it (article 1790(1) of the Civil Code). An action to rescind a donation for violence, error or fraud is barred after two years, counted from the end of the violence or the discovery of the error or fraud (articles 1222 and 1223). Heirs entitled to the reserved portion must sue for reduction within five years of the opening of the succession (article 1823).
What to do
Check that the donation exists in law. A donation is null if it is not made by a public deed (article 1753(1) of the Civil Code), which in practice means a deed received by a notary under the Notarial Profession and Notarial Archives Act (Cap. 55). The exceptions are manual gifts of money or movables of moderate value, regard being had to the condition of the persons, and certain gratuitous renunciations or assignments of debts (article 1753(2)).
The donation binds the donor only from the day the donee accepts it, and acceptance of a donation of immovables must be made in the deed itself or in another public deed (article 1754). If a flat was 'given' by handing over the keys without a notarial deed, or the donee never accepted, the donor may not need to revoke anything: the transfer may simply be null. Ask the notary for a certified copy of the deed before deciding on a strategy.
Read the deed for a resolutive condition or a reversion clause. Article 1785 allows revocation in virtue of a resolutive condition, express or implied, under articles 1066 to 1069. An express condition (for example, that the donation lapses if the donee sells the property within ten years) dissolves the donation ipso jure when it occurs, and the court may not grant extra time (article 1067).
The donor may also stipulate that the property reverts to him if the donee dies without issue, or predeceases him (article 1779). When the reversion takes place, any alienation is dissolved and the property returns free from burdens and hypothecs created by the donee (article 1780). If the deed contains such a clause, a judicial letter calling on the donee to recognise the dissolution is often the first step.
If the donation imposed a burden, consider the implied resolutive condition. A donation subject to an obligation, such as paying the donor a monthly sum or caring for an elderly parent, is an onerous donation; the rules on donations apply only to the extent that the value given exceeds the burden by at least one half (articles 1738 and 1740). Where the donee fails to fulfil the obligation, article 1068 implies a resolutive condition, but the agreement is not dissolved ipso jure and the court may give the donee a reasonable time to perform.
Under article 1069 the donor may choose between demanding dissolution and compelling performance, with damages in either case. Keep evidence of the burden and of every failure to perform it: bank statements, letters, and statements from carers or neighbours.
Assess whether the facts amount to ingratitude in law. Article 1787 lists three grounds only: (a) the donee attempted to take the donor's life or was guilty of cruelty or grievous injury towards him; (b) the donee wilfully, and with intent to cause injury, considerably damaged the donor's property or prejudiced his interests; (c) the donor was in urgent need of maintenance or personal assistance and the donee refused support which he could have given without great inconvenience.
Rudeness, family quarrels or refusal to visit are not enough. Under ground (c), also remember that a donee in possession of the property is in any case bound to maintain an indigent donor to the extent of the fruits of the thing given (article 1773). Revocation for ingratitude never operates automatically (article 1788): only a court judgment revokes the donation.
Respect the one-year deadline and the rules on who may sue. The demand for revocation on the ground of ingratitude can only be made within one year from the day of the offence or from the day on which the donor could have become aware of it (article 1790(1)). This period is short; do not let negotiations run past it without filing.
The donor cannot sue the heirs of the donee, and the heirs of the donor cannot sue the donee, unless the donor himself started the action or died within a year from the day of the offence (article 1790(2)). A renunciation of the right to revoke for ingratitude made before the offence is null (article 1789), so a clause in the deed waiving that right in advance does not bind the donor. Donations made in contemplation of marriage cannot be revoked for ingratitude, except those between the future spouses (article 1792).
File the action in the competent court. Revocation is sought by sworn application. Disputes concerning ownership of immovable property do not fall within the Court of Magistrates (article 47(3) of the Code of Organization and Civil Procedure, Cap. 12), so a donation of a house, flat or land is revoked before the Civil Court, First Hall. A donation of money or movables up to €15,000 against a defendant living in Malta may be brought before the Court of Magistrates (article 47(1)).
The application must set out the deed of donation, the ground relied on, the facts and dates showing that the action is in time, and the demand: revocation of the donation and return of the property, or its value. Attach the deed, police reports, medical certificates and correspondence. The donee has twenty days from service to file a sworn reply (article 158); if he does not, the court may proceed without hearing his defence.
Plan for property that the donee has already sold or mortgaged. Revocation for ingratitude does not affect alienations, hypothecs or other burdens made before the judicial demand for revocation (article 1791(1)). Instead, the donee must restore the value of the things alienated, assessed at the time of the demand, with the fruits from that day, and indemnify the donor for any hypothec on property not alienated (article 1791(2)).
Revocation under a resolutive condition is stronger: the property reverts free from all burdens and hypothecs imposed by the donee, and the donor has against third parties in possession of the immovables the same rights he would have against the donee (article 1786). If there is a risk that the donee will sell quickly, ask your lawyer about a precautionary warrant and file the judicial demand as early as possible, since the cut-off date in article 1791 is the date of that demand.
If you were pressured or deceived, sue for rescission instead. A donation, like any contract, can be annulled where consent was given by error, extorted by violence or obtained by fraud (articles 974 to 981 of the Civil Code). Undue influence over an elderly or dependent donor is usually argued as fraud or violence. A donation by a person who lacked capacity, such as a minor or a person interdicted, is null even if the incapacity later ceased (articles 1744 and 1745).
The action for rescission is barred after two years, running from the day the violence ended or the error or fraud was discovered (articles 1222 and 1223). Medical evidence of the donor's condition at the date of the deed and the notary's own recollection are often decisive.
Heirs: use reduction rather than revocation. A child or spouse cannot revoke a parent's donation for ingratitude. Their remedy, after the donor's death, is the action for reduction: donations that exceed the disposable portion are reduced to that portion (article 1813), starting with the most recent donation and only after the property disposed of by will has been exhausted (article 1818). Only those entitled to a reserved portion may demand reduction, and they cannot waive that right during the donor's lifetime (articles 1815 and 1816).
The action is barred five years after the opening of the succession, and the period runs even against minors (article 1823). Once judgment is given on immovables, the judgment is enrolled in the Public Registry under article 4 of the Public Registry Act (Cap. 56) so that third parties can see the change of title.
Take the tax position into account before transferring or revoking. For duty purposes a donation is a transfer like any other (definition of 'transfer' in article 2 of the Duty on Documents and Transfers Act, Cap. 364). Where a person donates immovable property to a descendant who will use it as his sole ordinary residence, the first €250,000 of value is disregarded and duty is charged at €3.50 per €100 on the rest, provided it is the first such transfer (article 32C).
If the descendant sells the property within five years, the relieved duty becomes payable at that time. Before signing a new deed, or a deed recording a revocation agreed between the parties, ask the notary to calculate the duty and confirm whether any relief must be repaid.
What to watch out for
- Waiting too long. The one-year period for ingratitude in article 1790 runs from the offence or from when the donor could have known of it; family attempts at reconciliation do not suspend it.
- Relying on a family argument as ingratitude. Article 1787 is exhaustive: only attempts on life, cruelty or grievous injury, wilful serious damage to the donor's interests, or refusal of urgently needed support qualify.
- Assuming the birth of later children revokes a gift. The Maltese Civil Code allows revocation only for a resolutive condition or ingratitude (article 1785); later children must rely on reduction of donations after the donor's death.
- Inserting a clause allowing the donor to take the gift back at will. Under article 1737(3) such a clause makes the donation void, which may defeat the parties' tax and succession planning.
- Ignoring sales already made by the donee. After revocation for ingratitude, third-party buyers and banks keep their rights acquired before the judicial demand (article 1791); the donor gets only the value.
- Treating an informal gift of a flat as valid. Without a public deed and acceptance in a public deed, a donation of immovables is null (articles 1753 and 1754), and the title remains with the donor or his heirs.
Legal basis
Frequently asked questions
Can I take back a house I donated to my son in Malta?
Only on the grounds in the Civil Code: a resolutive condition in the deed or an implied one if he failed to perform a burden (articles 1068 and 1785), or ingratitude in one of the three cases of article 1787. Changing your mind or a family dispute is not a ground. Revocation needs a court judgment and, for ingratitude, an action filed within one year.
What counts as ingratitude for revoking a donation?
Article 1787 lists three cases: an attempt on the donor's life, cruelty or grievous injury; wilful and considerable damage to the donor's property or interests with intent to injure; and refusal of support when the donor urgently needed maintenance or assistance and the donee could have helped without great inconvenience. Nothing else qualifies.
Is there a time limit to revoke a gift for ingratitude?
Yes, one year from the day of the offence or from when the donor could have become aware of it (article 1790(1) of the Civil Code). After that the right is lost. A waiver of the right signed before the offence happened is null (article 1789).
Can a donation be revoked if the donor later has children?
No. Unlike some other legal systems, Maltese law does not list the birth of children as a ground for revoking a donation; article 1785 allows only a resolutive condition or ingratitude. Children born later are protected after the donor's death through the action for reduction of donations that exceed the disposable portion (article 1813).
Does a donation in Malta have to be made before a notary?
Yes, as a rule. A donation is null if not made by public deed (article 1753). Manual gifts of money or movables of moderate value are the exception. For immovables, acceptance must also be in the deed or another public deed (article 1754).
What happens if the donee has already sold the property?
For ingratitude, sales and hypothecs made before the judicial demand stand; the donee must pay the donor the value at the time of the demand plus fruits (article 1791). Under a resolutive condition or reversion clause, the property returns free from burdens and the donor can act against third parties in possession (articles 1780 and 1786).
Can the heirs revoke a donation after the donor's death?
Only if the donor had already started the action, or died within a year from the offence (article 1790(2)). Otherwise heirs entitled to the reserved portion may sue for reduction of excessive donations within five years of the opening of the succession (article 1823).
Can a donation be cancelled if my elderly father was pressured to sign?
Yes, if consent was obtained by fraud or extorted by violence, the donation can be rescinded under articles 974 to 981 of the Civil Code. The action is barred after two years, counted from when the violence ended or the fraud was discovered (articles 1222 and 1223). Medical records from the date of the deed are important evidence.
Do I pay duty when donating property to my child in Malta?
A donation is a transfer for duty purposes. Where the child acquires the property as his sole ordinary residence and it is the first such transfer, the first €250,000 of value is ignored and the rest is charged at €3.50 per €100 (article 32C of Cap. 364). The relief is clawed back if the child sells within five years.
Practical legal guides
Analyse my document →Legal guideContract templatesCountry home page